The last several posts have been very interesting. Agree about the loudness wars issue. In general the band has gotten louder/heavier and the production is not helping. One intangible that people often point out is "breathing room". There was so much of it on I&W and parts of Awake. All those parts where its ambient keyboard, bass, infrequent drums and resonating guitar. So cool. Not much of it now, more like a roller coaster at all times. That's not to say I don't LOVE the alien, because I do. It's just different.
One thing I did notice last night during my listen of I&W into Awake is that, we commonly talk about train of thought/8VM as the key turning point for the band, but there's another MAJOR turning point to talk about. And that's JP's guitar work on Awake compared to I&W. His work on I&W is truly unbelievable. It's like he's playing a classical symphony during a heavy metal piece, and it works! Beautifully! His parts, while technically less complex, are musically and compositionally more complex. Anyway, he went from super complex, intricate stuff on Images to a "pure rocker" on Awake. In my estimation it's actually AWAKE, (not ToT), that changed the band's direction towards a more straight forward rocker (power chords, heavy lines vs I&W which were individual notes and large chords). Awake is awesome, as is a lot of material to follow, but I hope you see my point...