Here was my initial one-listen take on the tune:
Honestly, I like it. I don't "love" it, but I like it much better on first listen than any of their last couple of records on first listen. The song "breathes," the notes are not going a million miles an hour, and I like the keyboard style and tone on the intro.
The only thing I would argue is that given the simplicity (for DT) of the song, it didn't have to be 8 minutes. It could have been high fives, even six minutes. Some refinement might have taken this from "like" to "love" for me quickly.
That said, the song absolutely is a nice change of pace for DT. James is singing a lot more controlled, and as ShadowWalker and I discussed off the board, it's not very dynamic. That's strange, but it fits the tune. It would have fit better if they hacked off 90 seconds though.