I don't understand all the dislike for Lie I'm seeing, but I also can't really separate it from The Mirror, so maybe that's it.
As for the album, I'd say it's usually Top 3 for me, with Scenes and whatever else I'm feeling at the moment.
But it's weird, because I wouldn't say there's a Top-Top-Tier single song on it.
The whole is definitely greater than the sum of its parts, and I think what makes it so good is the consistent tone throughout.
And that totally makes sense, because Scenes is the same way.