Update now that the 2023 portion of the tour is over.
Counting songs from the main set, the few minor changes that were made along the way, and the below surprise songs, 173 songs played on the tour this year.
Guitar is always first, piano second, except where indicated.
2023
Glendale, AZ night 1: Mirrorball and Tim McGraw
Glendale, AZ night 1: This Is Me Trying and State of Grace
Las Vegas, NV night 1: Our Song and Snow on the Beach
Las Vegas, NV night 1: Cowboy Like Me (w/ special guest Marcus Mumford) and White Horse
Arlington, TX night 1: Sad Beautiful Tragic and Ours
Arlington, TX night 2: Death by a Thousand Cuts and Clean
Arlington, TX night 3: Jump Then Fall and The Lucky One
Tampa, FL night 1: Speak Now and Treacherous
Tampa, FL night 2: The Great War (w/ special guest Aaron Dessner) and You're On Your Own, Kid
Tampa, FL night 3: Mad Woman (piano - w/ special guest Aaron Dessner) and Mean (guitar)
Houston, TX night 1: Wonderland and You're Not Sorry
Houston, TX night 2: A Place in This World and Today Was a Fairytale
Houston, TX night 2: Begin Again and Cold As You
Atlanta, GA night 1: The Other Side of the Door and Coney Island
Atlanta, GA night 2: High Infidelity and Gorgeous
Atlanta, GA night 2: I Bet You Think About Me and How You Get the Girl
Nashville, TN night 1: Sparks Fly and Teardrops on My Guitar
Nashville, TN night 2: Out of the Woods and Fifteen
Nashville, TN night 3: Wouldve, Could've, Should've (w/ special guest Aaron Dessner) and Mine
Philadelphia, PA night 1: Gold Rush and Come Back...Be Here
Philadelphia, PA night 2: Forever & Always and This Love
Philadelphia, PA night 3: Hey Stephen and The Best Day
Foxborough, MA night 1: Should've Said No and Better Man
Foxborough, MA night 2: Question...? and Invisible
Foxborough, MA night 3: I Think He Knows and Red (both on guitar, since her piano malfunctioned due to rain from previous night)
East Rutherford, NJ night 1: Getaway Car (w/ special guest Jack Antonoff) and Maroon
East Rutherford, NJ night 2: Holy Ground and False God
East Rutherford, NJ night 3: Welcome to New York and Clean (the only repeat thus far)
Chicago, IL night 1: I Wish You Would and The Lakes
Chicago, IL night 2: You All Over Me (w/ special guest Maren Morris) and I Don't Wanna Live Forever
Chicago, IL night 3: Hits Different and The Moment I Knew
Detroit, MI night 1: Haunted and I Almost Do
Detroit, MI night 2: All You Had to Do Was Stay and Breathe
Pittsburgh, PA night 1: Mr. Perfectly Fine and The Last Time
Pittsburgh, PA night 2: Seven (piano w/ special guest Aaron Dessner) and The Story of Us (guitar)
Minneapolis, MN night 1: Paper Rings and If This Was a Movie
Minneapolis, MN night 2: Dear John and Daylight
Cincinnati, OH night 1: I'm Only Me When I'm with You and Evermore
Cincinnati, OH night 2: Ivy (w/ special guest Aaron Dessner), I Miss You, I'm Sorry (guitar also w/ special guest Gracie Abrams) and Call It What You Want (first show to get three songs in the surprise songs "eras" section)
Kansas City, MO night 1: Never Grow Up and When Emma Falls in Love
Kansas City, MO night 2: Last Kiss and Dorothea
Denver, CO night 1: Picture to Burn and Timeless
Denver, CO night 2: Starlight and Back to December
Seattle, WA night 1: This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things and Everything Has Changed
Seattle, WA night 2: Message in a Bottle and Tied Together in a Smile
Santa Clara, CA night 1: Right Where You Left Me (w/ special guest Aaron Dessner) and Castles Crumbling
Santa Clara, CA night 2: Stay Stay Stay and All of the Girls You Loved Before
Los Angeles, CA night 1: I Can See You and Marooned
Los Angeles, CA night 2: Our Song and You Are in Love
Los Angeles, CA night 3: Death by a Thousand Cuts and You're On Your Own, Kid
Los Angeles, CA night 4: Dress and Exile
Los Angeles, CA night 5: I Know Places and King of My Heart
Mexico City, Mexico night 1: I Forgot That You Existed and Sweet Nothing
Mexico City, Mexico night 2: Tell Me Why and Snow on the Beach
Mexico City, Mexico night 3: Cornelia Street and You're On Your Own, Kid
Mexico City, Mexico night 4: Afterglow and Maroon
Buenos Aires, Argentina night 1: The Very First Night and Labyrinth
Buenos Aires, Argentina night 2: Is It Over Now?/Out of the Woods mashup and End Game
Buenos Aires, Argentina night 3: Better Than Revenge and Slut!
Rio de Janeiro, Brazil night 1: Stay Beautiful and Suburban Legends
Rio de Janeiro, Brazil night 2: Dancing with Our Hands Tied and Bigger Than the Whole Sky
Rio de Janeiro, Brazil night 3: ME! and So It Goes...
Sao Paulo, Brazil night 1: Now That We Don't Talk and Innocent
Sao Paulo, Brazil night 2: Safe & Sound and Untouchable
Sao Paulo, Brazil night 3: Say Don't Go and It's Time to Go