Train of NaughtOn the Verge of CollapseCallisto – Wormwood
Dystopia Na! – Shadowcasting Horologe
Dystopia Na! – Through Mirrors, Darkly
Exquirla – Canción de E
Exquirla – Destruidnos Juntos
The Angelic Process – Dying in A-MinorFirst Impression - Heavy, moving, epicI was initially super excited about this EP. Unfortunately that excitement waned a bit after repeated listens. I also kind of wish I let you keep the original last track, but rules are rules.... Granted, this EP is still pretty good, so let's get to it.
First off is Wormwood. I do really like this track. It has this slow descent into madness as the music slowly turns darker. It's kind of a cool musical idea. It also works well for the story here. Which by the way is dark and poignant and really telling of the times we live in. Ooh and there's a saxophone in this. It brings a lovely atmosphere to an otherwise dark and brooding song. Also the lighter instrumental part in the back half of the track is really beautiful in a dark sort of way. After a not so great transition we move into the two Dystopia Na! songs. These have a great buildup of atmosphere and brooding sense of dread. I think these two songs are probably my favorite part of the EP, especially Through Mirrors, Darkly. This song has such a nice intense buildup with a good payoff. The vocals are very fitting for the story and work well for me. There's also some great quieter moments that remind me of Opeth's lighter moments in their heyday. I'm struggling to determine what genre these guys should be classified as, because I've never really heard anything quite like this. They are almost like a Depressive Black Metal band that wanted to write catchy Prog rock melodies. This song is a true journey from start to finish. It goes through so many twists and turns, but maintains that dark atmosphere. The song might be a little longer than necessary, but that's the only negative I can think of here. So another transition that I'm not particularly fond of and now we get to the part where I feel the EP takes a turn for the worse. This band, Exquirla, I'm not really big on their style. It's mostly straight up Post-Metal, without anything to truly make it stand out. The great atmosphere that Dystopia Na! had isn't here. There is a buildup, but the ultimate payoff isn't really anything special. Cancion de E seems to serve as an intro/lead-in to Destruidnos Juntos. The beginning of this song actually works for me, but the biggest issue I have with this song is the vocals. I just don't really like them. Now, I did end up translating the lyrics and they work really well for the story. It's just unfortunate I don't like the song more. Now we come to the biggest problem with this EP. I know you had to make a last second change from your original song, which actually is a fantastic song and would have ended this wonderfully. Unfortunately the song you picked doesn't work well within the context of the EP. The song itself is OK. It's in dire need of a remix or remaster thought. The production is too bassy and crackly. Which might be the point, as far as atmosphere is concerned, but it doesn't exactly work for me here and now. Especially when the rest of the EP has very clear production.
Song quality starts off really good with Callisto and Dystopia Na!, but then starts to go downhill fast after that.
(7.2/10)I like how the story sort of parallels what is going on in the world right now with this whole Covid-19 thing and the possibilities that could await us. It's dark and depressing. The song lyrics do a fairly good job of expressing the story too.
(8/10)The flow is probably the weakest part of the EP. The transitions between each of the respective artists isn't great and kind of takes me out of the enjoyment of the EP. The disparity between each of the artists, with the exception of Callisto and Dystopia Na! is noticeable. Especially with The Angelic Process.
(2/5)I know I kind of castrated the ending of your EP when I had to ban Kampfar and overall this could have been so much better. Sometimes that's just the way the cookie crumbles.
Overall Score (17.2/25)
Final Scores!
Ariich - 16.25, 17.25, 12.5, 12, 17.7, 18, 16, 16.7, 17.7, 23.6 = 167.7
Train - 18.5, 19, 16.7, 13, 13.6, 16.9, 17, 17.9, 17.2, 17.2 = 167
Kattelox - 17.5, 14.7, 14.2, 18.9, 14, 16.5, 16.5, 17.8, 15.8, 20.9 = 166.8
Romdrums - 17, 16.75, 18.7, 16.5, 16, 14, 16, 15.5, 15.5, 19.1 = 165.05
Elite - 10.5, 16, 17, 18.6, 14.2, 14.5, 16.8, 17.8, 14.9, 19.7 = 160
Nekov - 17, 16, 14.8, 14.3, 16.5, 15, 12, 16.3, 18.4, 16.5 = 156.8
Cyril - 15.25, 18.25, 16.5, 17, 14, 13, 16.1, 17.5, 12.2 = 139.8
Tomislav - 16, 16, 16.5, 16, 12.5, 15, 16, 12.4, 13 = 133.4
Lethean - 13.5, 16.5, 11, 18.2, 11.6, 14.5, 12.5, 16, 16.4 = 130.2
TAC - 11, 11, 17.2, 16, 14.5, 11, 17, 15.5, 16.5 = 129.7
Stadler - 14, 16.3, 14.2, 11, 13.5, 17, 10.5, 13.5, 14 = 124
And we have an upset, come from behind win!
Thanks again to all the participants. I've received so much good music this roulette. This may be my last roulette for a while. I have some other things in mind to do, as I mentioned earlier in the thread. More on that in a bit.