The album's definitely a grower. I do like it, but there's nothing here that can compete with my favorite NW tracks. I love the concept behind the album, but it lacks the diversity that the last two had.
Floor is a really good singer but here she sounds a bit too restrained and generic. Anette put a lot of passion into her delivery and made herself stand out, which is why I miss her in the band.
The good news is that Dawkins' parts are mercifully short and actually pretty tasteful, unlike the droning on Song of Myself.
Overall, I wouldn't call this essential Nightwish material, but it's definitely enjoyable.