Pink Floyd Survivor 2012 - The Wall Round 1 Disc 2

[Unlegit]

Disc 1

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.

Disc 2

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.

Vera, but Stop could go too.

[Mladen]

Stop

I like disc 2 much better than disc 1, I gotta say. All of these are great, whereas there are a couple of meh tracks on disc 1.

[Buddyhunter1]

STAHP

[Scorpion]

STAHP

[Ħ]

Uh...Stop is basically the most climactic moment of the record, and you guys are voting it off? Well ok.

This is hard. The Show Must Go On, I guess.

[SomeoneLikeHim]

Uh...Stop is basically the most climactic moment of the record, and you guys are voting it off?

yup

[jammindude]

Stop is in my top 5 for the ENTIRE album! 

Bring the Boys Back Home.

[Scorpion]

Also, most overrated PF album ever. Never, ever got the hype, easily the least enjoyable one of the classic albums for me. In fact, I'd rate Meddle and The Division Bell considerably higher than this album.

[Lolzeez]

Uh...Stop is basically the most climactic moment of the record, and you guys are voting it off? Well ok.

This is hard. The Show Must Go On, I guess.

[Lucidity]

Waiting for the Worms. Whoever voted for Comfortably Numb... I will find you, and I will kill you.

[Unlegit]

Waiting for the Worms. Whoever voted for Comfortably Numb... I will find you, and I will kill you.

Luckily, no one did??

[Lucidity]

Waiting for the Worms. Whoever voted for Comfortably Numb... I will find you, and I will kill you.

Luckily, no one did??

My mistake; I thought someone had, but it was the song above it 

[Elite]

Voting for Stop.. 

I voted Bring the Boys Back Home.

[Orbert]

Outside the Wall

[Ħ]

Also, most overrated PF album ever. Never, ever got the hype, easily the least enjoyable one of the classic albums for me. In fact, I'd rate Meddle and The Division Bell considerably higher than this album.

Ah! I disagree. The Wall is very well-placed at the top of most Top Rock Albums lists. Not only is it Floyd, but it's got that a very emotional pang to it as well.

[Scorpion]

Yeah, I guess I could never connect with the emotional content of the album, I guess I'm weird like that. Plus, I think the music could easily be condensed into one CD - I know, you'd have to sacrifice the concept, but see the first part of my post for that - this way, there's too much filler going on here for me to consider it one of PF's best. It's still great, but I never liked it as much as many other people do.

[Ħ]

As a high school introvert that felt very detached from society, I closely connected with the album's theme. Perhaps that's why I love it so much.


But most people here on DTF think it's overrated, bloated, and too lengthy. So you're not alone in your opinion.

[Scorpion]

Again, I don't necessarily think that it's bad. Songs like Hey You or Comfortably Numb would sit comfortably in my Top 10 PF songs, it's just that some don't do as much to me as I think they have the potential to do, and that is not a problem that Meddle, The Division Bell, DSOTM, WYWH and Animals have, so it kinda falls flat against those. If a lesser band than PF had released The Wall, it would probably be the pinnacle of their career, but in the context of PF's entire catalogue, it just doesn't match up.

[jjrock88]

Bring the boys

[Dillster22]

Vera

[wasteland]

Also, most overrated PF album ever. Never, ever got the hype, easily the least enjoyable one of the classic albums for me. In fact, I'd rate Meddle and The Division Bell considerably higher than this album.

Yeah, I guess I could never connect with the emotional content of the album, I guess I'm weird like that. Plus, I think the music could easily be condensed into one CD - I know, you'd have to sacrifice the concept, but see the first part of my post for that - this way, there's too much filler going on here for me to consider it one of PF's best. It's still great, but I never liked it as much as many other people do.

Again, I don't necessarily think that it's bad. Songs like Hey You or Comfortably Numb would sit comfortably in my Top 10 PF songs, it's just that some don't do as much to me as I think they have the potential to do, and that is not a problem that Meddle, The Division Bell, DSOTM, WYWH and Animals have, so it kinda falls flat against those. If a lesser band than PF had released The Wall, it would probably be the pinnacle of their career, but in the context of PF's entire catalogue, it just doesn't match up.

Let's be friends

[?]

Bring the Boys Back Home

[Mladen]

Damn, I fail to see what's so climatic about Stop. It couldn't even dream of being the most climatic song on the album. Especially because The Trial follows, that's where the album reaches its peak musically, and even lyrically it covers the entire album it its five minutes of epicness. And suddenly a song of 30 seconds is more climatic? It just serves as an intro to The Trial, that's all it is in my opinion.

As for the concept, I think it's genius. It's probably the greatest story ever told in the history of rock music.

[jammindude]

Damn, I fail to see what's so climatic about Stop. It couldn't even dream of being the most climatic song on the album. Especially because The Trial follows, that's where the album reaches its peak musically, and even lyrically it covers the entire album it its five minutes of epicness. And suddenly a song of 30 seconds is more climatic? It just serves as an intro to The Trial, that's all it is in my opinion.

As for the concept, I think it's genius. It's probably the greatest story ever told in the history of rock music.

The "intro for The Trail" thing might be accurate...but the way it comes off the crescendo in Waiting for the Worms is (for me) the biggest emotional climax of the entire album.   Everything on the entire album comes to a head at that *exact* moment...for me anyway. 

[Mladen]

Yeah, the transition from Waiting for the worms to Stop is pretty rad, I'll admit that.