Alright, since I can't edit the OP, here's the final results of the all the album tournaments:
Kill 'Em All:
Winners:
The Four Horsemen
Seek & Destroy
Consolation:
3. Whiplash
Rest:
4. Jump in the Fire
5. Motorbreath
6. No Remorse
7. Hit the Lights
8. Phantom Lord
9. Metal Militia
10. Anesthesia (Pulling Teeth)
Ride the Lightning:
Winners:
Ride the Lightning
Creeping Death
Consolation:
3. Fade to Black
Rest:
4. For Whom The Bell Tolls
5. The Call of Ktulu
6. Fight Fire With Fire
7. Trapped Under Ice
8. Escape
Master of Puppets:
Winners:
Puppetz
Sanitarium
Consolation:
Battery
Rest:
4. Orion
5. Heroes
6. Damage
7. Thingy
8. Messiah
...And Justice For All:
Winners:
Blackened
One
Consolation:
Justice
Rest:
4. Dyers
Harvie
6. Eye
7. To Live
8. Frayed Ends
9. Straw
The Black Album:
Winners
Unforgiven
Wherever I May Roam
Consolation
Nothing Else Matters
Rest:
4. Sandman
5. Sad
6. Misery
7. Wolf
8. God
9. Struggle
10. Never
11. Holier
12. Tread
Load:
Winners:
Bleeding Me
The Outlaw Torn
Consolation:
Until It Sleeps
Rest:
4. King Nothing
5. Ain't My Bitch
6. The House Jack Built
7. Mama Said
8. Thorn Within
9. Hero of the Day
10. Cure
11. 2x4
12. Wasting My Hate
13. Poor Twisted Me
14. Ronnie
ReLoad:
Winners:
Low Man's Lyric
Fixxxer
Consolation:
Unforgiven II
Rest:
4. Fuel
Devil's Dance
6. Where The Wild Things Are
7. The Memory Remains
8. Prince Charming
9. Slither
10. Carpe Diem Baby
11. Bad Seed
12. Better Than You
13. Attitude
Garage, Inc. Disc 1:
1. Mercyful Fate
2. Turn the Page
3. Whiskey in the Jar
4. Astronomy
5. Sabbra Cadabra
6. Tuesday's Gone
7. It's Electric
8. Die, Die, My Darling
9. Free Speech for the Dumb
10. The More I See
11. Loverman
Garage, Inc. Disc 2:
1. Am I Evil?
2. Breadfan
3. The Prince
4. Helpless
5. Blitzkrieg
6. Stone Cold Crazy
7. Killing Time
8. Last Caress/Green Hell
9. Too Late, Too Late
10. Stone Dead Forever
11. Damage Case
12. The Wait
13. The Small Hours
14. Overkill
15. Crash Course in Brain Surgery
16. So What
St. Anger:
Winners:
Frantic
The Unnamed Feeling
Consolation:
St. Anger
Rest:
4. All Within My Hands
5. Shoot Me Again
6. Some Kind of Monster
7. Sweet Amber
8. Invisible Kid
9. Dirty Window
10. My World
11. Purify
Death Magnetic
Winners:
1. All Nightmare Long
2. That Was Just Your Life
Consolation
3. The End of the Line
Rest
4. The Judas Kiss
5. Cyanide
6. The Day That Never Comes
7. Broken, Beat & Scarred
8. Unforgiven III
9. My Apocalypse
10. Suicide & Redemption
I just noticed that there are no album winners for all the other albums, but oh well.