Yeah, YOTBR's production did not suit Coheed at all. Props for trying something different, but I don't think Atticus Ross or Joe Barresi were suited for music like Coheed's. They're more about dense, claustrophobic atmosphere, I think, which is why they work so well with NIN/Trent Reznor and Tool. Coheed's albums usually sound more open, if that makes sense, especially on the Good Apollo albums, as well as Afterman. I do like the rawness of SSTB though, and would be fine with a return to that sound as well.