Bill, opinions aside I hope you realize that I don't want to lose you as a listener. Don't let what others say here change your opinion of the show! Personally, if it's in my realm and appropriate for the show I'll usually play something despite my opinion of it. I have always tried to get listeners involved with the show, but at the same time we can't just say request anything and we'll play it.
========================
On the main topic at hand, I will just say that I personally don't find bands that are influential to be better than newer bands that haven't been. Sure, I thank them for their contributions and inspiring bands I do like, but that is not reason for me to enjoy their music, because quite simply either I like them or I don't.