I don't know, gave it a five, listened to it two times, actually I tend more to a three.
For me it does not sound as a unit, everybody plays his stuff, on german you say,
They really tried hard but couldn't deliver(viel gewollt, nicht gekonnt).
And. I really liked portnoys drumming in DT, the las CD where i really digged his drumming was Nightmare, his drumming would have been perfect for AS.
I will check them out live, if theey come close, but overall I am dissapointed