1. Black Clouds & Silver Linings – One of my favorites and one of the forum least favorites. Bookended by two top ten tracks, which would be enough, and everything in the middle is pretty good too.
2. Falling Into Infinity – Not exactly hated here, at least not as much as in the fanbase at large, but definitely deserves more love. Like BCSL it has two top 15 tracks in Trial of Tears and Lines in the Sand. Hollow Years is also EXCELLENT, and Take Away My Pain and New Millennium are underrated. Not a bad track on here (before any of you express disagreement or possibly concern for my sanity, I want to tell you that's alright, I'm okay, it happens every single day, it's all the same, but I'm not blind).
3. Dream Theater – Could have gone with WDADU here, because I really do like that one, but I think the forum rates it appropriately (I rate it #11), so it wouldn't make much sense for me to put it. DT12 does make sense for me to put here, because this one was actually underrated by me until about a month ago. I didn't give this album the credit it deserves for the longest time, but just a little while ago it worked its way into being one of my favorites. One of the most consistent albums, which I think is also true of ADTOE. DT12 doesn't reach the same peaks as some of DT's albums, but it is one of their best because of its quality throughout.