How is this thread silly? It's one of Rush's most well known and best songs up against a song that was made as tribute to Rush. Seems pretty logical to compare them for funsies.
It was destined to become a Rush vs. Coheed thread, though. And I think most of the board has a very clear-cut opinion on that matter.
To be honest, I don't get the comparisons, as in calling Coheed and Cambria "a modern Rush" or something like that. It doesn't make a whole lot of sense. And the two songs are really very, very different besides the name.