MAYH has been the victim of unlucky timing for me. I downloaded a crop of random Opeth tracks back in '04 and loved 'em. Problem was the majority were from BWP and I was in the middle of a shift when I was a driver at Domino's one day and just HAD to have an Opeth album but the only CD place in my delivery area (we could be heavily disciplined if caught driving in another store's delivery area) was Barnes and Noble. They only had MAYH so I said fuck it and got it. Very good album with a vibe all its own that I like a lot to this day as I do all of their stuff except for half of Watershed and Heritage.
Problem was, while I was listening to awesomeness like April Ethereal, When, Demon of the Fall, and Karma, I was just thinking "Fuck, I really wanna hear The Leper Affinity, Bleak, etc." Just think of being on a date with a pretty cute chick the day after finding out a girl you carried a torch for during a very long period of time is getting married but with less crying and consolation masturbation at the end of the night (but not that much less.)