Yeah, looks like I'm in the outcast camp. I really want to like it, but I don't. There are sporadic outbreaks of sheer brilliance, as to be expected given the talent level of the band, but overall the songs just don't do it for me. Random thoughts:
Infinite Fire is awesome. Shame the whole album isn't more like it.
Dave LaRue is the fucking man.
Though he's nowhere near as talented as Rudess, I've decided I like Neal Morse better as a keyboard player. Quite a bit better, in fact.
Portnoy over plays at times. Odd for me to think that because I generally love his style.