Dream Theater: The Astonishing (now with moment of betrayal!)

[Awaken]

I get that's what was referred to as the teaser.  Guess i took that comment as sarcasm

[ericoml]

To who listened TA more than us: The Gift of Music can be considered at which point of the album average quality? It's one of the best songs? How good it is compared to the others?

[Thematt202]

I get that's what was referred to as the teaser.  Guess i took that comment as sarcasm

You might have a point actually.  Never thought of it like that... 

Can any of the "special" people put us out of our collective misery?

[MegaDTSX]

I really like The Gift of Music.  I don't know if its pushing the boundaries on what cannot be asked, but if anyone who has listened to any more of the album could tell me this:


Is The Gift of Music a good precursor of "what is to come" from The Astonishing?  I know its hard to simplify or compare progressive music, even on a single album, but the pacing and just the quality of that song is pretty good.

[bosk1]

I think Noxon and I have said about all we can/will say on the subject, so continuing to ask questions is pointless (and kind of insulting).  Please stop.  You all can wait 3 1/2 more weeks for the album (or for any information that is officially released or authorized before then).

[Kotowboy]

I think Noxon and I have said about all we can/will say on the subject, so continuing to ask questions is pointless (and kind of insulting).  Please stop.  You all can wait 3 1/2 more weeks for the album (or for any information that is officially released or authorized before then).

WHEN ARE YOU GOING TO LEAK IT ?

[bosk1]

Right after I finish banning you.  Give me a moment.

[Train of Naught]

[Thematt202]

I think Noxon and I have said about all we can/will say on the subject, so continuing to ask questions is pointless (and kind of insulting).  Please stop.  You all can wait 3 1/2 more weeks for the album (or for any information that is officially released or authorized before then).

Insulting how, exactly?  You're both regularly posting cryptic snippets of information then apparently getting pissed off when people try to engage with you about the subject.  Perhaps think about who is really insulting who.

This is a forum of die-hard DT fans and you're lucky enough to receive privileged information.  With great power, etc etc.   

[ericoml]

I don't think asking personal opinion insulting, we just want to know how much did you liked. We are not asking for specific information or to spoil the album

[RMGadelha]

Uh oh...

[BelichickFan]

Main problem is all these questions have been answered.  We already know that those who have heard it have said TGoM is not typical of the CD and not in the top rung in terms of quality.  It's a crazy long thread but these questions have been answered.

[Train of Naught]

Just drop it guys, we'll get an update soon enough (the actual album is coming out in just about 3 weeks), it's not like you have to devote all your time to counting down to the album, just carry on with whatever you do and before you know it there's a new update, or maybe even the album.

[Gonz]

I don't think asking personal opinion insulting, we just want to know how much did you liked. We are not asking for specific information or to spoil the album

You can look on What Are Your Thoughts On "The Gift of Music's thread to know that.

But I think the same, too much spoilers in the last week. I  (and I think the whole forum) really appreciate the info snippets, but don`t expect they're gonna talk openly about the songs yet. Just take a look to the music websites and magazines, still no reviews or comments.

Just a little patience. Wait until tomorrow.

[Enigmachine]

It's times like this when it would make sense to lock the thread until the next update. 141 pages is a hell of a long thread.

[bosk1]

I think Noxon and I have said about all we can/will say on the subject, so continuing to ask questions is pointless (and kind of insulting).  Please stop.  You all can wait 3 1/2 more weeks for the album (or for any information that is officially released or authorized before then).

Insulting how, exactly?  You're both regularly posting cryptic snippets of information then apparently getting pissed off when people try to engage with you about the subject.  Perhaps think about who is really insulting who.

Okay, perhaps "insulting" is a bit too strong.  But Noxon and I have NOT been "regularly posting cryptic snippets of information" as you suggest.  Noxon has posted some things in response to specific questions, and I am annoyed that a few people keep ignoring statements that we are not allowed to say much more.  But I do indeed realize that this is a forum of hardcore fans.  So, yeah, I understand that people are going to ask anyway.  I apologize for letting my annoyance spill over and get the better of me.  I do realize that it is just because you guys are just anxious, and that that is because you are fans of the band.  But just please understand that we are not in a position to be able to say much, so just please don't push too hard.  It isn't long before you will all be able to hear the entire album in all its glory.

[King Postwhore]

How dare you give us info without getting yourself in trouble bosk1?!  How dare you!

[Podaar]

I do realize that it is just because you guys are just anxious, and that that is because you are fans of the band.  But just please understand that we are not in a position to be able to say much, so just please don't push too hard.  It isn't long before you will all be able to hear the entire album in all its glory.

So we can push...if we're gentle?

[bosk1]

I do realize that it is just because you guys are just anxious, and that that is because you are fans of the band.  But just please understand that we are not in a position to be able to say much, so just please don't push too hard.  It isn't long before you will all be able to hear the entire album in all its glory.

So we can push...if we're gentle?

Well, maybe YOU can. 

[King Postwhore]

I do realize that it is just because you guys are just anxious, and that that is because you are fans of the band.  But just please understand that we are not in a position to be able to say much, so just please don't push too hard.  It isn't long before you will all be able to hear the entire album in all its glory.

So we can push...if we're gentle?

Bet you say that to all the guys.

[Thematt202]

I think Noxon and I have said about all we can/will say on the subject, so continuing to ask questions is pointless (and kind of insulting).  Please stop.  You all can wait 3 1/2 more weeks for the album (or for any information that is officially released or authorized before then).

Insulting how, exactly?  You're both regularly posting cryptic snippets of information then apparently getting pissed off when people try to engage with you about the subject.  Perhaps think about who is really insulting who.

Okay, perhaps "insulting" is a bit too strong.  But Noxon and I have NOT been "regularly posting cryptic snippets of information" as you suggest.  Noxon has posted some things in response to specific questions, and I am annoyed that a few people keep ignoring statements that we are not allowed to say much more.  But I do indeed realize that this is a forum of hardcore fans.  So, yeah, I understand that people are going to ask anyway.  I apologize for letting my annoyance spill over and get the better of me.  I do realize that it is just because you guys are just anxious, and that that is because you are fans of the band.  But just please understand that we are not in a position to be able to say much, so just please don't push too hard.  It isn't long before you will all be able to hear the entire album in all its glory.

Sorry for starting drama, of course I appreciate where you are coming from.  I was just thinking out loud about whether or not we're gonna receive some more news/content this week.  I thought you were trying to invite some discussion with your "this is gonna be a good week *popcorn*" comment . 

[The Paddies]

My 2 cents: if you consider The Gift Of Music to be an 8-, the album will be a 9+. ;-)

[RMGadelha]

My 2 cents: if you consider The Gift Of Music to be an 8-, the album will be a 9+. ;-)

Wow, that is amazing because I consider TGOM to be amazing and better than OTBOA and The Enemy Inside as a single.

[Thematt202]

I agree, it's a great song.

[bosk1]

I think Noxon and I have said about all we can/will say on the subject, so continuing to ask questions is pointless (and kind of insulting).  Please stop.  You all can wait 3 1/2 more weeks for the album (or for any information that is officially released or authorized before then).

Insulting how, exactly?  You're both regularly posting cryptic snippets of information then apparently getting pissed off when people try to engage with you about the subject.  Perhaps think about who is really insulting who.

Okay, perhaps "insulting" is a bit too strong.  But Noxon and I have NOT been "regularly posting cryptic snippets of information" as you suggest.  Noxon has posted some things in response to specific questions, and I am annoyed that a few people keep ignoring statements that we are not allowed to say much more.  But I do indeed realize that this is a forum of hardcore fans.  So, yeah, I understand that people are going to ask anyway.  I apologize for letting my annoyance spill over and get the better of me.  I do realize that it is just because you guys are just anxious, and that that is because you are fans of the band.  But just please understand that we are not in a position to be able to say much, so just please don't push too hard.  It isn't long before you will all be able to hear the entire album in all its glory.

Sorry for starting drama, of course I appreciate where you are coming from.  I was just thinking out loud about whether or not we're gonna receive some more news/content this week.  I thought you were trying to invite some discussion with your "this is gonna be a good week *popcorn*" comment . 

Well, the events that were on the schedule I have were supposed to have happened already, so...not sure where we are.    But it is supposed to be a good week.

[RMGadelha]

[King Postwhore]

I love how fast the newbs learn our emotes.

[bosk1]

[Prog Snob]

[RMGadelha]

I love how fast the newbs learn our emotes.

I have to admit that I click on quote to remember some of them, even though I'm not that much of a newb anymore xD

[King Postwhore]

I love how fast the newbs learn our emotes.

I have to admit that I click on quote to remember some of them, even though I'm not that much of a newb anymore xD

We all need the cheat sheets for them.  BTW Looks at my post count.  I'm an old fart here now.

[Enigmachine]

Well, the events that were on the schedule I have were supposed to have happened already, so...not sure where we are.    But it is supposed to be a good week.

That sounds a little awkward. If I were to guess, these things will probably come friday because why not.

[RMGadelha]

Well, the events that were on the schedule I have were supposed to have happened already, so...not sure where we are.    But it is supposed to be a good week.

That sounds a little awkward. If I were to guess, these things will probably come friday because why not.

The album will be released on a friday. It seems friday is a nice day for everything, so yeah, why not? 

[bosk1]

We all need the cheat sheets for them.  BTW Looks at my post count.  I'm an old fart here now.

And new ones are being added all the time!  In fact, I just added one 8:41 ago.

(which, by that clue, King should be able to figure out what it is and what the code is, if he thinks about it hard enough)

[King Postwhore]

Son of a


I'm having a brain fart.