Stadler, you can't have it both ways. If you truly believe that all individuals have the right to choose for themselves, then that means that you must believe in at the very least creating a level playing field so to speak to enable everyone to have the opportunity to choose without fear of harm. You can't say everyone has the right to choose, so long as it falls in line with my beliefs. That anyone who cannot be vaccinated is just what, "shit out of luck" because forcing others to do something to help eliminate the spread of disease is wrong? I mean why don't we just allow people to not use public toilets to remove and control human waste? Isn't that the same thing? If we allowed people to just take a dump wherever they felt like it, that leads to the spread of disease quicker than just about anything you can imagine. Forcing people to use indoor plumbing in populated areas is a form of "control" is it not?
And a large contributor to this current outbreak of measles IS the antivaxxers. We had pretty much eliminated or controlled the spread of measles in this country by the herd immunity concept. It's a numbers game. More people refuse to vaccinate their kids, the greater the chance, and the likelihood, for the spread of the disease.
People like Jenny McCarthy have done serious damage to the foundation of the vaccination effort. It used to be that people were just playing Russian Roulette before the various vaccines became available. Take Polio for instance, people lined up like crazy to get their families immunized once the vaccine was developed. Then it became more of an education thing. People who came from countries who didn't know about the importance of immunizations, and those who came from poorer area's who were either too illiterate or too poor to know why it was important or have the means to do so became the targets of the educational efforts. Then when the antivax movement really took off, it was an uphill battle for the health community because they were seen as co-conspirators in some vast effort to what, kill off kids?
Unless you have some medical reason NOT to be immunized, it should be mandatory. As part of the human race, there are certain expectations that should be required of all of us.
I guess a couple of work around scenarios on this matter should be 1) Insurance companies should have the right to deny coverage for people who could otherwise get vaccinated. So if you refuse to have your child immunized for any other reason than a bonafide health condition that prevents it, then they have the right to not cover the child with insurance; and 2) allow a public school to require that parents keep their children out of school in the event of an outbreak of a contagious disease for which they refused vaccination, and not allow the children back into school until the threat has been deemed to have ended by public health authorities. This way, the parents must weigh their perceived risk of vaccinating their child against the risk of their child missing a significant amount of school days, and potentially being held back again and again.