Porcupine Tree Survivor - In Absentia - Round 4

[RoeDent]

ROUND 3 RESULTS

Lips of Ashes - 2
The Sound of Muzak - 2
Prodigal - 2
Heartattack in a Layby - 1
Strip the Soul - 5
Collapse the Light Into Earth - 2

Strip the Soul is eliminated.

Ranking

1.
2.
----------
3.
----------
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9. Strip the Soul
10. .3
11= Wedding Nails
    = The Creator Has a Mastertape

--------------------------------

Four down, eight remaining. 24 hours to vote.

[?]

Another epic fail...

Collapse is alright, but not particularly compelling compared to the majority of songs on this album, because it's just the same piano melody played over and over again.

[Elite]

Another epic fail...

Collapse is alright, but not particularly compelling compared to the majority of songs on this album, because it's just the same piano melody played over and over again.

Strip the Soul is my second favourite on this album.

Voted Collapse.

[BlackInk]

This album and 'Daedwing' are the only two PT albums I know well enough to participate. Voted 'Prodigal', never stuck with me as most of the others. Also, '.3' is awesome, sad it's out.

[Evermind]

The Sound of Muzak

[Nekov]

The Sound of Muzak

[Elite]

Well, out of the songs left, Prodigal should make Consolation and Heartattack and Blackest Eyes should go to the Finals.

Sorry about my ranting on this album's survivor in particular

I just have very string feelings for this album

[Mladen]

Fair enough, that was one of my lesser favorites as well.

Prodigal, a bland, forgettable and average song in the bunch of absolutely fantastic Porcupine Tree classics.

[hefdaddy42]

Lips of Ashes

[Tom Bombadil]

Lips of Ashes

Yes