Dream Theater: The Astonishing (now with moment of betrayal!)

[Kotowboy]

In my opinion - A Dramatic Turn Of Events is the best RoadRunner album so far.

I agree...but I think your statement will change soon.

Hence "so far". 

[RaasMah]

Darius is the military Genral who will end up as the real bad guy and try to overthrow Lord Nafa after he welcomes Gabriel music.

spoilers ffs man.. ffs

Its a complete guess man I havent heard the album.

[Quarter_Cask]

so is it basically about 2 brothers a woman and a tragedy?

[RoadTrain_of Thought]

Darius is the military Genral who will end up as the real bad guy and try to overthrow Lord Nafa after he welcomes Gabriel music.

EDIT:Nvm, realised it might be a spoiler

[metrojam]

AdToE was good but by the numbers and DT12 was stale. Getting an album now that is so different is refreshing.

I keep hearing this type of statement on the forum. Over and over and over. Do people really think that if they keep saying it, it will come true?

But what part of that statement isn't true?.....I think you'll find that once you've heard the album you will realise that it is SPOT ON!!

[IdoSC]

AdToE was good but by the numbers and DT12 was stale. Getting an album now that is so different is refreshing.

I keep hearing this type of statement on the forum. Over and over and over. Do people really think that if they keep saying it, it will come true?

But what part of that statement isn't true?.....I think you'll find that once you've heard the album you will realise that it is SPOT ON!!

I'm assuming he referred to the people who call ADTOE by the numbers or DT12 stale, not the latter part about TA.

[pringkaarwanda]

Umm, this about the second video in DT website
Can it be an official Video clip from one of the song in the album?

If yes, then I really love they make Video Clip for Dystopian Overture.
From all review, it said Dystopian Overture is perfect instrumental song to describe future / Dystopian atmosphere in the album
It will be very great to have a video clip of Dystopian Overture, showing all thing that relate to the album, using 3D animation or something, so it can make all of our fantasy come alive when we watch it 

That's the vibe I got when I heard this. Just seems like the camera will go from the NOMAC (in Descent) to a pan of the city then go on a flying tour all through the GNE/Ravenskill etc. Definitely seems like certain places have certain themes of music as well as the different characters

Yes !! I love it if DT make 3D animation video that shows us every place in The Astonishing story
It will raise my fantasy and more enjoy the story, because my brain will start to imagine place, vibe & atmospherefor that match with every situation in the story 

[Podaar]

AdToE was good but by the numbers and DT12 was stale. Getting an album now that is so different is refreshing.

I keep hearing this type of statement on the forum. Over and over and over. Do people really think that if they keep saying it, it will come true?

But what part of that statement isn't true?.....I think you'll find that once you've heard the album you will realise that it is SPOT ON!!

I'm assuming he referred to the people who call ADTOE by the numbers or DT12 stale, not the latter part about TA.

You assumed correctly, sir.

[bosk1]

I'm with you, Podaar.  Opinions are opinions, but calling ADTOE "by the numbers" or DT12 "stale" are pretty empty criticisms that I can't take seriously.

[BlobVanDam]

I don't think there's anything at all empty about calling ADTOE by the numbers. I happen to strongly agree with that one. On DT12, I wouldn't call it stale, but I find it thoroughly uninteresting aside from a few sections.

[bosk1]

Yes, but you missed an all-so-important piece of the puzzle.  Since when do I ever take your opinions seriously?

[BlobVanDam]

Probably about twice as often as I take yours seriously.

[Podaar]

I really love this place, bosk. I sincerely do.

I'm sure we all know it's just opinions and I understand that the last two albums might not be their thing, but DT12 stale? I'm sure folks can come up with better criticisms. 

[bosk1]

Probably about twice as often as I take yours seriously.

Haha!  Well played. 

[Progmetty]

In my opinion - A Dramatic Turn Of Events is the best RoadRunner album so far.

I think it's the best thing since Six Degrees, I like all the albums in between in different variations but ADToE still blows my mind and has become my go-to when I feel like DT since it's release day.
Also the only album that I instantly fell in love with since SFAM, on my first listen I battled with repeating every track or finish listening to the whole album first. I was singing along the chorus to Bridges on my third run through the album!

[vazquez]

In my opinion - A Dramatic Turn Of Events is the best RoadRunner album so far.

Yes, for sure. Many great songs.

DT12 is good, but it has not aged well. Each year that passes, I listen to it less and less. I still listen to ADTOE a lot.

[RaasMah]

Darius is the military Genral who will end up as the real bad guy and try to overthrow Lord Nafa after he welcomes Gabriel music.

EDIT:Nvm, realised it might be a spoiler

If it is then I swear I did not knew this. It just seems like the go-to story arc. And Darius face seriously looks evil, while Nefarius a bit more on the wiser side.

[pdurbin22]

With less than 48 hours until the release, I'm shocked - and thrilled - the album hasn't leaked yet. At least not anywhere I know of. I was too damn weak with ADTOE and DT12 and listened to most songs well ahead of the release dates. Kudos to those working hard to keep this thing off the interwebs so weaklings like me don't ruin our release-day experience!

[bosk1]

[DarkLord_Lalinc]

I'm hoping bad for some kind of making of video, with the orchestra/choir recording process, JR and JP bouncing music ideas out from each other, arrangements with David Campbell, etc. that would probably be the most interesting making of video DT's ever put out. The best them.

[r3d86]

So, The E-Mails from Arhys and Nafaryus was the last update until Release Date?

[TAC]

I'm hoping bad for some kind of making of video, with the orchestra/choir recording process, JR and JP bouncing music ideas out from each other, arrangements with David Campbell, etc. that would probably be the most interesting making of video DT's ever put out. The best them.

I agree.

[DarkLord_Lalinc]

So, The E-Mails from Arhys and Nafaryus was the last update until Release Date?

I dunno, there's still another video that's gonna be released in the website.

[r3d86]

So, The E-Mails from Arhys and Nafaryus was the last update until Release Date?

I dunno, there's still another video that's gonna be released in the website.

Yep, and the Places section! And JP said that on the Release Date the lyrics with some explanation for understand the situation, also characters bio will be on the site.

But I just can't wait anymore! 

[pdurbin22]

Apologies Bosk - my post was definitely anti-leak but please feel free to delete it if it's going to cause any issues!

[erwinrafael]

For those interested, The Astonishing would be released in HDTracks on release date.  Best option for somebody like me who has a hard time accessing physical CDs. I hope DT would post early on their website what is the discount code, I missed the discount for BTFW. 

[BlobVanDam]

For those interested, The Astonishing would be released in HDTracks on release date.  Best option for somebody like me who has a hard time accessing physical CDs. I hope DT would post early on their website what is the discount code, I missed the discount for BTFW. 

Excellent! In the past the HDTracks release has trailed behind by a decent amount, so a lot of people bought the album twice who would have preferred to only buy the HDTracks version.
Although this time I don't think the HDTracks version is as necessary, since the main benefit was the slightly better master.

[DarkLord_Lalinc]

lol I first read Yanni's album title like 'Yanni - Serious Chill' and I was like 'OMG amazing Yanni album title' but then I was disappointed.

[chrisgazpacho]

I'm hoping bad for some kind of making of video, with the orchestra/choir recording process, JR and JP bouncing music ideas out from each other, arrangements with David Campbell, etc. that would probably be the most interesting making of video DT's ever put out. The best them.

I hope it was documented.  If there is any release that deserves a making of it's this one.  That being said I'm not counting on it, from the sound of the interview with Eddie Trunk this was a very expensive project so a documentary on top of it would probably break the budget.

[erwinrafael]

For those interested, The Astonishing would be released in HDTracks on release date.  Best option for somebody like me who has a hard time accessing physical CDs. I hope DT would post early on their website what is the discount code, I missed the discount for BTFW. 

Excellent! In the past the HDTracks release has trailed behind by a decent amount, so a lot of people bought the album twice who would have preferred to only buy the HDTracks version.
Although this time I don't think the HDTracks version is as necessary, since the main benefit was the slightly better master.

Yep, I think it's more now an option for those who's buying a FLAC/ALAC download rather than an mp3 download or a physical CD.

[thosava]

The HDtracks download is unquestionably the best version even if the difference is very small. It will definatly sound better than an mp3 download.

[metrojam]

I really love this place, bosk. I sincerely do.

I'm sure we all know it's just opinions and I understand that the last two albums might not be their thing, but DT12 stale? I'm sure folks can come up with better criticisms. 

You're quite right, everyone has their own opinions and are entitled to them and if "stale" is not the right word to describe DT12, then here's another one that sounds quite similar and to me sums up that album...."sterile" 

Like we say, its all "opinions" but I'm pretty damn sure I won't be using similar words to describe TA though!!

[YtseJohn]

From Facebook:

HDtracks
26 mins ·
TODAY ONLY, Get 10% off ALREADY REDUCED pricing on every Dream Theater title in the store in celebration of their new album, The Astonishing, available on Friday. Use code DREAMDAY. https://www.hdtracks.com/music/artist/view/id/4386/

[Kotowboy]

I'll wait. If the CD is as dynamic as people are saying I don't need it. 

[BFRedrocks]

The HDtracks download is unquestionably the best version even if the difference is very small. It will definatly sound better than an mp3 download.

Isn't this the same thing as the FLACs we are supposed to get (have access to download) via the box set purchase?

The Astonishing Digital FLAC Album     
1 x The Astonishing Digital FLAC Album 016861748951   N/A