News:

DreamTheaterForums is a place for people who just don't have the time for music anymore. 

Main Menu

Enigma Machine

Started by KevShmev, September 26, 2013, 11:37:56 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

RodrigoAltaf

 I think the drum fill of the year award should go to Mike Mangini for what he does in this song.

Crow

Easily the best song on the new album, the only one that is interesting. Really some great riffs and soloing here too, only complain is, yeah, bass solo is underwhelming. It's very similar to Erotomania though, a 20-years-later rendition of it or something, at least that's what it makes me think.
turns out signatures are fundamentally broken now so here's my passive-aggressive signature about signatures instead

Sycsa


GalacticGuitarist87

It is very similar to Erotomania, I thought the same thing. It sounds nothing like it but the structure or something is similar. And they are both track 4 lol, not that that makes a difference. 

ariich

Quote from: sylvinception on October 07, 2013, 06:31:29 AM
Don't like it.

Still listen to it to try to like it.

Still don't know exactly why I don't like it - yet ?

== >> Work in progress == >> I'll let you know. :loser:
Quote from: sylvinception on October 08, 2013, 03:49:35 AM
FINALLY the miracle happens!!

After many listening, I finally learned to love this huge piece of awesome music!! :metal
That took less than a day. :lol

Quote from: Buddyhunter1 on May 10, 2023, 05:59:19 PMAriich is a freak, or somehow has more hours in the day than everyone else.
Quote from: TAC on December 21, 2023, 06:05:15 AMI be am boner inducing.

sylvinception

Told you it was a miracle!! ;D

Cygnus17

I think its great.  Short and powerful, especially the drums, which really drive the song.  Love how it ends with a vengeance.  Great tune to stick in the middle of the album.

Jaq

Love Enigma Machine. It's well put together, has some nice riffs and great solos, and MM fucking kills it. It's relatively compact-SOC is just too fucking long-and doesn't overstay its welcome. Great song.

Octawakeimages

This is up there with my favorite instrumentals.  It really needs multiple listens before you can really judge it, it's a lot to take in.  Once you can memorize the main riff, you should be good to go!  :metal

OsMosis2259

Love the inspector gadget riff :)

JiM-Xtreme

One of the only songs to really "grab" me on the first listen, and still one of my favourites on the album.

kirksnosehair

Gotta learn the riffs from this one. 

Virtualman64

Freakin love it! I love the unisions especially,which is probably what I like the most about DT's music.Also,I love all the solo's buy the guys.Awesome!

Ħ

EM is not the best song on DT12, but it's fun. Reminds me of The Ytse Jam.

KevShmev

Happily, this song has grown on me in a major way.  Very fun song indeed, and pretty great to drive to. :metal

energythief

Gotta go listen a few more times. I usually skip it, as instrumentals don't hold my attention. But reading all the praise for it is piquing my interest in a huge way!

SystematicThought

Mangini's fill towards the end sounds amazing to listen to on surround sound. It lives up to the name surround sound

Cable

Not my favorite DT instrumental, but better than my least favorite. And I liked EM when I first heard it.

kirksnosehair

Quote from: KevShmev on October 12, 2013, 08:42:59 PM
Happily, this song has grown on me in a major way.  Very fun song indeed, and pretty great to drive to. :metal


I caught myself doing 50mph in a 35mph zone yesterday.  I realized after I slowed down that every time this song comes on while I'm driving I speed up  :lol   

adamack

Though I like EM a *bit* better than I did at first, I still consider it to be very lacking in melody for my personal taste.

To me, it's  my 2nd least fav on DT12, after The Looking Glass.

And for everyone who has said something about the bass solo being pathetically short, I just wanted to say: HELL YEAH! Same goes for the drum solo. I was expecting the solo spots to be actual lengthy solos, perhaps at least 10-15 seconds or so each.

The drum "solo" is awesome, definitely not hating on it, but I wish both the drum and bass solos were longer.

With all that said, I still think the track is okay. Just pales in comparison to most of the rest of the album, IMHO.

Sycsa

I wouldn't change a thing about the drum solo, I think it's the most effective this way. A longer solo could break the flow and wouldn't pack such a punch. I love short solos like this, Virgil Donati's on Clonus is one of my all-time favorite drum moments (and this one is up there as well).

ishak540m

The beginning of this song has replaced the BITS throatsinging as my ringtone.

?

According to JP the drum solo was originally even shorter, but MM wanted to extend it a bit and they allowed him to do so.

Lowdz

It did nothing for me at first but now I love it as much as the rest of the album. The MM bits just bring a smile to  my face for some reason.

Grizz

I could see an extended YYZ/YtseJam style drum solo live.

The Letter M

Quote from: Grizz on October 17, 2013, 12:52:55 PM
I could see an extended YYZ/YtseJam style drum solo live.

This would be neat, especially if we get an extended bass solo spot for Myung as well!

-Marc.

AngelBack

Don't know if this has been mentioned or if anyone saw it, but on the TV show Pawn Stars, a guy brought in an Enigma Machine to sell on the show last night.  Said there were only 4 known in the US.  He wanted 250k for it, so they had the expert come in and evaluate, turns out his model had some replacement parts and was only worth 70k.
Were used by the German field generals in WWII to encrypt messages.  Turns out we cracked the code early on but had to underplay how much we knew so they would not recalibrate.

But as the owner of the pawn shop was looking at it he said, "the coolest thing about this thing is the name - Enigma Machine"   :metal

Kotowboy

Quote from: Sycsa on October 16, 2013, 02:08:09 AM
I wouldn't change a thing about the drum solo, I think it's the most effective this way. A longer solo could break the flow and wouldn't pack such a punch. I love short solos like this, Virgil Donati's on Clonus is one of my all-time favorite drum moments (and this one is up there as well).

The drum break on " Don't Look Back In Anger " is a really nice moment too. Short and sweet.

rumborak

Quote from: AngelBack on October 18, 2013, 10:28:28 AM
Don't know if this has been mentioned or if anyone saw it, but on the TV show Pawn Stars, a guy brought in an Enigma Machine to sell on the show last night.  Said there were only 4 known in the US.  He wanted 250k for it, so they had the expert come in and evaluate, turns out his model had some replacement parts and was only worth 70k.
Were used by the German field generals in WWII to encrypt messages.  Turns out we cracked the code early on but had to underplay how much we knew so they would not recalibrate.

I'm assuming you're British? They were the ones decrypting the Enigma Machine to my knowledge (Alan Turing and stuff).

Grizz

This is one of the only DTXII songs I enjoy, but one thing drives me crazy: the effect that keeps getting used on the drums. I don't know what it's called, but it has that "whoosh" feeling and is very prevalent in Rainbow's Rising.

Tis BOOLsheet

It really stretches the word "solo" to call any drum or bass moment on the song a "solo." A real bass and/or drum solo could have been amazing, and a new DT moment. Love the drums on EM, but that is a fill, not a "solo."

Lowdz

Quote from: rumborak on October 18, 2013, 12:15:57 PM
Quote from: AngelBack on October 18, 2013, 10:28:28 AM
Don't know if this has been mentioned or if anyone saw it, but on the TV show Pawn Stars, a guy brought in an Enigma Machine to sell on the show last night.  Said there were only 4 known in the US.  He wanted 250k for it, so they had the expert come in and evaluate, turns out his model had some replacement parts and was only worth 70k.
Were used by the German field generals in WWII to encrypt messages.  Turns out we cracked the code early on but had to underplay how much we knew so they would not recalibrate.

I'm assuming you're British? They were the ones decrypting the Enigma Machine to my knowledge (Alan Turing and stuff).

But Hollywood rewrote history again. John Bon Jovi captured it before becoming even shorter.

Cygnus17

Enigma is great.  Took a little bit to really grow, but I love it now and think its perfectly placed on the album.

fadetoblackdude7

This song is underrated like a MoFo.....really fun, and every instrument just goes crazy. Yet it still has that musical hook that keeps coming back (the Inspector Gadget-like theme)

Grizz

Enigma Machine reminds me of the good parts of Stream of Consciousness while not dragging on like the latter.