I'll also add that it's interesting that it seems to be a fairly polarizing song, with many fans really loving it, and others ranking it near the bottom. And it's interesting that I don't remember it being that polarizing until relatively recently. At least online, I remember it being generally well liked by the majority.
Love this song - my favorite from FII. In particular I love they way they played it in 2002.
I'm trying to remember--was that when they added the extended last chorus section back in to where it was similar to the original demo version?
EDIT: Found this really shortened version, but I don't think this is what you meant, is it (although James is really on fire on this one!)?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4PRFn9y4qccI think you mean more like this version from Bucharest:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2XsyzlGxuFY I like the general arrangement, but I don't like how James takes more of the response part on the call-and-response chorus (I think it would be better if he really went for it on the "call" like he does on the version above and let MP take Dug's "response" part). The extended guitar solo is REALLY tasty in a live setting. Someone in the comments in that video posted "This solo is a combination of Steve Vai, David Gilmour, and Petrucci's signature styles all mixed together." That's really a great description. At times, he really let's it breathe like Gilmour. At other moments, he goes into super shred mode. Still others, he does these kind of "out there," creative things like Vai would. And it all somehow works together really nicely. And lastly, yeah, they DID add the extended chorus section at the end, which is cool.
I hadn't listened to this song in a long time prior to this, and had forgotten how much I miss it. It's great in a live setting, but it's a really great song in its own right anyway. It got me thinking that if I were to make my own "ultimate" version of Falling Into Infinity, it would probably look something like:
1. Caught in a New Millenium (LSFNY version)
2. Peruvian Skies
3. Raise the Knife
4. Hell's Kitchen (no, I still don't like it, but it serves as a great intro to LITS)
5. Lines in the Sand
6. Take Away My Pain
7. Just Let Me Breathe (LSFNY version)
8. Anna Lee
9. Trial of Tears