The reason I don't like the album is because it has an extremely corny metal vibe to it. Songs like Afterlife sound like they could be Sonata Arctica (check out 8th Commandment). Sonata Arctica is fun little power metal band, but DT should never have to sink to their level.
The melodies on practically the whole album are very poorly constructed, especially the vocal melodies. The production is terrible. Dominici is terrible.
By DT standards, there is little that this album has to offer. (in real world standards, WDADU dominates, don't get me wrong)
In all honesty, I can understand why a person would like the album, but I cannot see how a person could rank this album above any of the others.
Don't suffer from the common case of liking the oddball element simply because you think no one else does. I see this constantly, in people that say WDADU is their favorite album, in people that say Gimli is their favorite character in LOTR, in people that say their "political ideals" are different from the norm, etc. Stop lying to yourself, and let yourself like what you really like, without thinking about societal consequences. Remember, you're unique. Just like everybody else.