Could be a blasphemy to say this on DT forum, but everything on TTOE is better than The Astonishing. I don't agree about the short tracks part though, I've got plenty that are amazing and particularly touching for me, the examples being TTOE pt. 1, The Consultation, Dark Medicine, Fluctuations / Transformation, Side Effects, Mirror of Dreams and The Lighthouse. I know I have this unusual fondness for this album, and I can see how some people can dislike it, but I will defend it with whatever I have. I think it's a brilliant album.
And speaking of that, everything on The Human Equation is better than TTOE.