I've always felt White Pony is a bit overrated. I find everything from Saturday Night Wrist onward is more interesting and consistent. I would even say Koi No Yokan is the best thing they've done yet.
Blasphemy! White Pony is the best!
I love Saturday Night Wrist, a lot of people don't rate it too well, but its great, but I wouldn't say its consistent. It's very start/stop. That's what makes White Pony so beautiful, every song fits perfectly. Very cohesive.
I really like Koi No Yokan. But like I've said earlier, it sounds somewhat too "busy". That's the word I'll use to describe it. Or chaotic. It's still great, but it feels like there are too many things going on at once, like too many guitar tracks on top of one 'another. I don't know if that's actually the case, but that's how it sounds. I'm hoping with this next album they learned to streamline the sound better.