So, thinking about this the other day; TFF is by far the worst of the reunion albums, and is the just the lowest point in a discography that has fallen steadily worse since BNW. BNW is an absolutely stellar album, with DOD not far behind it. AMOLAD, despite it being a fan favourite, never grabbed me in the same way the first two did. TFF fails to grab me in every way; the concept, the artwork and certainly the music. The whole sci fi thing is just cringe-worthy, over-used and just.... lame. In short, its bollocks.
I think the thing that brings down AMOLAD and TFF is the lack of diversity in the tracks. Everything is just too samey, even for Maiden. BNW and DOD have a lot of diversity and the songwriting, especially in terms of the 3 guitars, is inspiring. There's none of that in AMOLAD and TFF. Just the same old gallopy VI-VII-I bullshit. Maiden needs to rethink their game plan or call it a day. Another album like TFF and that's their credibility down the drain, IMO; I don't know if I can sit through another album of average Maiden again.
Don't get me wrong, I'm no basher. I've loved Maiden since I was 5 years old, no bullshit. Kids at school were reading Goosebumps and Star Wars novels during silent reading time and I was reading Run To The Hills (the Maiden bio). Some of the fondest memories I cherish have a Maiden track as the backdrop
. Its like I'm seeing a good childhood friend become a shadow of their former self. It saddens me.
My 2c.