Okay, I'm coming around on this album. After the first two listens, I was so disappointed that I deleted the files (yes, I downloaded them - sue me). But after all this talk about "what genre is it?" and "electronica" I gave it another shot. To me honest, I still don't hear "electronica" any more than I did before. It's different, but it's still rock and roll. The wide diversity of styles makes it rather proggy to me, but some were saying it's definitely not prog (but that's probably coming from people with pretty narrow definitions of prog).
Anyway, it's a lot catchier than I gave it credit for, the production is excellent, and I guess I'm getting used to Kevin's vocals. They still bug me a little, and sound pretty lifeless, but they're interesting, and if you regard them as something like another instrument, another sound amidst the confusion, it works better. For me, anyway.
So two listens, then a week or two away from it, and two more listens. It's growing on me. I probably had my expectations all screwed up the first time. Mistake.