I’ve been thinking about what songs they might want to play for this first tour with Portnoy/their “40th anniversary “ tour.
I don’t think them calling it their 40th anniversary tour means it’s a guarantee that they’ll play a song from every album, but I’d say its a strong possibility, and I think it’d be a fun way to start off this next chapter of the band while highlighting all of their eras thus far. If they went the route of a song from every album + 4-5 from DT16, that would obviously put some limitations on the longer songs.
I have to imagine MP would like to do the full 12 Step Suite with the band. It’s not a guarantee, but I’ll be a bit surprised if they never do it. They don’t need that to be the spotlight on this first go around, and I think a great concept for a future tour would be to do the 12SS as a second set of an Evening With show, and then finally play Octavarium as the encore. So with that wishful thinking on my part, I’ve avoided adding any of those 6 songs to a potential set.
I also ignored doing a chronological set. It’s expected, and it can limit what songs you can pick from certain albums for the sake of the flow of the show. With all of that in mind, I came up with the following:
ACT I
1. DT16 Song
2. DT16 Song
3. 6:00 (I know they just played this but I wouldn’t be surprised if MP wants to play one of his most famous intros. If not this song then I’d forsee The Mirror being picked)
4. Blind Faith (I would’ve picked TGP if not this)
5. Sleeping Giant (can be swapped for The Alien)
6. DT16 Song (depending on how long the new songs are. If this didn’t fit, this would be cut)
7. The Gift of Music (I can see Our New World being chosen instead, but this was the lead single and I like it much more than ONW)
8. Constant Motion (another legendary MP drum part during JP’s solo and hasn’t been played worldwide in 14 years)
9. A Rite of Passage (both of the shorter BC&SL songs are some of DT’s weakest. This is the lesser of 2 evils, so to speak)
10. Outcry (Hasn’t been played since the ADToE tour cycle, and would be a fun Mangini era surprise. If not, BAI or OtBoA seem likely)
————————————————————
ACT II
11. As I Am (They seem to like playing this one, and it’s always fun, even if it’s been played a ton. I would prefer Honor Thy Father, but I feel like I remember MP saying something that made it sound like he wouldn’t want to play it anymore based off the subject of the song? If that’s incorrect, then I would choose it over AIA)
12. Panic Attack (Like CM, a great concert song that was only played a handful of times with Mangini during the 2015 festival run. Otherwise it hasn’t been played since
MP left, and that’s a shame.)
13. DT16 Song
14. Peruvian Skies (Been over a decade since it was played for a full tour)
15. The Dance of Eternity (TSCO seems like the obvious choice so I would love a surprise here. I’d imagine there’d be at least one instrumental in the set, and this one would be great to see with MP again)
16. Behind the Veil (Same concept as Panic Attack and CM, except they’ve played this one even less. They could hit the last three notes in TDoE and slide right into the full band intro to this. I’d also welcome the premiere of Surrender to Reason here)
17. S2N (Hoping this debuts soon. If not, I’d expect Barstool Warrior)
18. Only A Matter of Time (My favorite off WDaDU, and I know JP has expressed interest in playing it)
19. DT16 closing track
——————————————————
20. Metropolis (I would prefer this over PMU, but it could go either way. But one of them will absolutely be played)
That clocks in at 115 min before DT16 songs, which I think leaves about 40 min for the new album. Depending on how long the songs are, I would predict 4-5 of them will be played on this tour, with hopefully the others played on the proceeding run. Tried to do an even blend of songs I want to see and songs I actually presume will happen, but doing a highlight of all 16 albums is certainly doable, even with their massive catalog.