Sorry for triple posting.
But if I'm going to run a NIN survivor, it's going to include Hesitation Marks, so it should begin somewhere in September/October.
This is how I have planned it. The longer the album, the more songs to the finals. The Fragile is separated into two discs and Ghosts I-IV is omitted:
Pretty Hate Machine: 2 to finals, 1 to consolation
Broken: 2 to finals, 1 to consolation
The Downward Spiral: 3 to finals, 2 to consolation
The Fragile (Left): 2 to finals, 2 to consolation
The Fragile (Right): 2 to finals, 1 to consolation
With Teeth: 3 to finals, 2 to consolation
Year Zero: 3 to finals, 1 to consolation
The Slip: 2 to finals, 1 to consolation
Hesitation Marks: 3 to finals, 1 to consolation
Miscellaneous: 3 to consolation
Consolation: 15 songs, 3 to finals
Finals: 25 songs
Songs in miscellaneous round:
Get Down, Make Love (Queen cover, Sin B-side)
(You're So) Physical (Adam and the Ants cover, bonus track on Broken)
Suck (Pigface cover, bonus track on Broken)
Burn (Natural Born Killers soundtrack)
Dead Souls (Joy Division cover, The Crow soundtrack)
The Perfect Drug (Lost Highway soundtrack, Halo 11 (though the Halo consists only of remixes)
10 Miles High (The Fragile vinyl)
The New Flesh (The Fragile vinyl)
The Great Collapse (Things Falling Apart)
Metal (Gary Numan cover, Things Falling Apart)
Deep (Lara Croft: Tomb Raider soundtrack)
Home (Non-US pressings of With Teeth)