As for The Astonishing, I would be surprised to see them do the whole thing again (unless they decided to revisit the idea of pulling it out for a one-off or a few shows to record it, but I would assume it would be heavily advertised that way). But I see no reason they wouldn't do individual songs from it. I would actually expect them to. I wouldn't put too much weight on that MP comment that was quoted above. First off, the context of that comment is important. That was being said in response to what SOA might do at a time when the idea of MP actually being back in DT and playing DT songs within DT was not on anyone's radar. It wasn't meant to be taken as "I hate The Astonishing, and if I'm ever back in DT, there's no way I would play anything from it!" Second, and related, him being back in DT is the difference. I doubt there is little, if any, Mangini era material that is "off limits" in his mind. It is DT material, and he is a member of DT again. And it is pretty clear he does not have any resentment or bad feelings toward Mangini whatsoever. And a couple of observations about set lists when he was in DT the first time: (1) He regularly lobbied for songs in the set lists that then-current members did not originally play on, whether it was James singing Another Won or WDADU songs, or Derek playing songs from the first three albums, or Jordan playing songs from the first four albums. (2) He often brought up songs other members had not played in a long time and had to relearn or songs they had not played at all and had to learn from scratch. I doubt he would change course now and not apply those two things to himself. He's a VERY capable drummer and musician, cares about the fans and what would make for a good set, and is a professional. I'm sure that the vast majority of the Mangini catalog would be fine with him if asked (and there might even be some songs he actively wants to learn and play).