I think we all know that Yessongs and Yesshows will end up 1 and 2.
I can't remember if I bought 9012Live, but I know I heard it back in the day. I have the VHS tape, which is great, but it isn't the same content as the album, which is just "meh."
I also own videos from the House of Blues and Symphonic Live shows. Don't know if it's the same content as the albums, but they're both very good (Symphonic Live is particularly enjoyable, and a big part of it is the unbridled enthusiasm of one of the reed players).
AFAIK, I've never heard the three most recent, and I've only heard bits and pieces of the BBC Recordings.
Hence, I voted for In the Present.