Top 25 Favorite Drummers countdown thread! (Number 1 & 2 Up!)

[pg1067]

I think it will be interesting to see whether any band (perhaps I'm thinking of one band in particular) gets multiple drummers in the countdown and, if so, how they rank relative to each other.

I've got two from one band, which coincidentally happens to be the same two guys who were also in my top 10 singers...

I'm going to stretch my fat ass out on that limb and say you all are not talking about the same band/drummers.

I'm actually curious to whom HOF was referring.  I don't know any bands that have/had two drummers sing enough that anyone would consider them top 25 drummers and singers.

[HOF]

I think it will be interesting to see whether any band (perhaps I'm thinking of one band in particular) gets multiple drummers in the countdown and, if so, how they rank relative to each other.

I've got two from one band, which coincidentally happens to be the same two guys who were also in my top 10 singers...

I'm going to stretch my fat ass out on that limb and say you all are not talking about the same band/drummers.

I'm actually curious to whom HOF was referring.  I don't know any bands that have/had two drummers sing enough that anyone would consider them top 25 drummers and singers.

To be fair, one of the two drummers only played on half of one album for this one band and did not sing for that band.

[SwedishGoose]

I have three drummers from one band... none of them in my top singers though

[ReaperKK]

One thing I want to mention again is please, PLEASE check your spelling. There are a ton of misspellings that a simple google would take care of. Like "Peter Chris" for example, really guys? common...

I don't mind correcting lists as I go but don't get sour if I miss something and your boy loses a spot cause the name is misspelled and skewed the results.

[Kram]

I think it will be interesting to see whether any band (perhaps I'm thinking of one band in particular) gets multiple drummers in the countdown and, if so, how they rank relative to each other.

I've got two from one band, which coincidentally happens to be the same two guys who were also in my top 10 singers...

I'm going to stretch my fat ass out on that limb and say you all are not talking about the same band/drummers.

I'm actually curious to whom HOF was referring.  I don't know any bands that have/had two drummers sing enough that anyone would consider them top 25 drummers and singers.

If you’re not familiar with the band in his profile photo, and specifically the drummer from that band, it would be tough to figure out.

[Stadler]

I think it will be interesting to see whether any band (perhaps I'm thinking of one band in particular) gets multiple drummers in the countdown and, if so, how they rank relative to each other.

I've got two from one band, which coincidentally happens to be the same two guys who were also in my top 10 singers...

I'm going to stretch my fat ass out on that limb and say you all are not talking about the same band/drummers.

I'm actually curious to whom HOF was referring.  I don't know any bands that have/had two drummers sing enough that anyone would consider them top 25 drummers and singers.

To be fair, one of the two drummers only played on half of one album for this one band and did not sing for that band.

I know.  One of those guys is all OVER my list; the other, sadly, not even considered. 

[HOF]

I think it will be interesting to see whether any band (perhaps I'm thinking of one band in particular) gets multiple drummers in the countdown and, if so, how they rank relative to each other.

I've got two from one band, which coincidentally happens to be the same two guys who were also in my top 10 singers...

I'm going to stretch my fat ass out on that limb and say you all are not talking about the same band/drummers.

I'm actually curious to whom HOF was referring.  I don't know any bands that have/had two drummers sing enough that anyone would consider them top 25 drummers and singers.

To be fair, one of the two drummers only played on half of one album for this one band and did not sing for that band.

I know.  One of those guys is all OVER my list; the other, sadly, not even considered.

Should be though!

[pg1067]

I think it will be interesting to see whether any band (perhaps I'm thinking of one band in particular) gets multiple drummers in the countdown and, if so, how they rank relative to each other.

I've got two from one band, which coincidentally happens to be the same two guys who were also in my top 10 singers...

I'm going to stretch my fat ass out on that limb and say you all are not talking about the same band/drummers.

I'm actually curious to whom HOF was referring.  I don't know any bands that have/had two drummers sing enough that anyone would consider them top 25 drummers and singers.

If you’re not familiar with the band in his profile photo, and specifically the drummer from that band, it would be tough to figure out.

I'm probably not, but the pictures are too small for me to know for sure.   

[Stadler]

I think it will be interesting to see whether any band (perhaps I'm thinking of one band in particular) gets multiple drummers in the countdown and, if so, how they rank relative to each other.

I've got two from one band, which coincidentally happens to be the same two guys who were also in my top 10 singers...

I'm going to stretch my fat ass out on that limb and say you all are not talking about the same band/drummers.

I'm actually curious to whom HOF was referring.  I don't know any bands that have/had two drummers sing enough that anyone would consider them top 25 drummers and singers.

If you’re not familiar with the band in his profile photo, and specifically the drummer from that band, it would be tough to figure out.

I'm probably not, but the pictures are too small for me to know for sure.   

Have we identified that band?  Have we confirmed my guess or is it another band?  )

[Glasser]

Genesis.

[jingle.boy]

One thing I want to mention again is please, PLEASE check your spelling. There are a ton of misspellings that a simple google would take care of. Like "Peter Chris" for example, really guys? common...

So you're expecting George Peter John Criscuola??   

[ReaperKK]

One thing I want to mention again is please, PLEASE check your spelling. There are a ton of misspellings that a simple google would take care of. Like "Peter Chris" for example, really guys? common...

So you're expecting George Peter John Criscuola??   

More likly Gerg P3te Jon Crisscola

[SwedishGoose]

Saw Änglagĺrd yesterday.... Mattias Olsson.... what a muscician. Drummer / percussionist extrordinaire.

Reminds me a lot of Pat Mastllotto in King Crimson altough Mattias was the sole drummer here


Almost ready to update my list

[Stadler]

Genesis.

What about HOF's avatar?  Top left could be Mike, but I don't see any "Genesis" in the other three pictures.

[KevShmev]

One thing I want to mention again is please, PLEASE check your spelling. There are a ton of misspellings that a simple google would take care of. Like "Peter Chris" for example, really guys? common...

I don't mind correcting lists as I go but don't get sour if I miss something and your boy loses a spot cause the name is misspelled and skewed the results.

Welcome to my world.    Enjoy!

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

One thing I want to mention again is please, PLEASE check your spelling. There are a ton of misspellings that a simple google would take care of. Like "Peter Chris" for example, really guys? common...

I don't mind correcting lists as I go but don't get sour if I miss something and your boy loses a spot cause the name is misspelled and skewed the results.

Welcome to my world.    Enjoy!

I'm not sure how anyone would misspell one of their favorite musicians names. Having said that, I hope I didn't accidentally misspell something on my list.

[HOF]

Genesis.

What about HOF's avatar?  Top left could be Mike, but I don't see any "Genesis" in the other three pictures.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=m02Do2ShXvI&pp=ygUUYmlnIGJpZyB0cmFpbiBlbXBpcmU%3D

[Kram]

Genesis.

What about HOF's avatar?  Top left could be Mike, but I don't see any "Genesis" in the other three pictures.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=m02Do2ShXvI&pp=ygUUYmlnIGJpZyB0cmFpbiBlbXBpcmU%3D

Big Big Train has become my 3rd favorite band of all time, only behind Rush and Dream Theater.  NDV is one of my favorite musicians and is top 5 on my drummers list.  The other guy also ranked high on my drummers list LOL

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

Genesis.

What about HOF's avatar?  Top left could be Mike, but I don't see any "Genesis" in the other three pictures.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=m02Do2ShXvI&pp=ygUUYmlnIGJpZyB0cmFpbiBlbXBpcmU%3D

Big Big Train has become my 3rd favorite band of all time, only behind Rush and Dream Theater.  NDV is one of my favorite musicians and is top 5 on my drummers list.  The other guy also ranked high on my drummers list LOL

Oh boy, I completely forgot about NDV. Although I doubt he would have cracked my top 25, he definitely would be in the top 50.

[wolfking]

List sent!

[ReaperKK]

Got em! Final few days left, 19 lists so far!

[The Realm]

My list is in. Looking forward to this. A few drummers are pretty obvious and then after that will be very interesting to see how it plays out.

[twosuitsluke]

Sent my list 

[Dream Team]

List sent!

Is yours mostly metal guys like mine? 

[TAC]

List sent!

Is yours mostly metal guys like mine? 

It's probably a safe bet.

[wolfking]

List sent!

Is yours mostly metal guys like mine? 

Oh, are there other genres eligible are there?

[wolfking]

List sent!

Is yours mostly metal guys like mine? 

It's probably a safe bet.

HEY!  You can't talk! 

[Adami]

List sent!

Is yours mostly metal guys like mine? 

Oh, are there other genres eligible are there?

The genres eligible are metal, rock, prog, prog rock, prog metal, and one list with a surprising amount of Korean and Japanese metal.

[KevShmev]

This forum will have officially jumped the shark if Lars Ulrich makes the top 25. 

[LithoJazzoSphere]

List sent!

Is yours mostly metal guys like mine? 

Oh, are there other genres eligible are there?

The genres eligible are metal, rock, prog, prog rock, prog metal, and one list with a surprising amount of Korean and Japanese metal.

There will be multiple jazz-fusion players on mine. 

[Adami]

List sent!

Is yours mostly metal guys like mine? 

Oh, are there other genres eligible are there?

The genres eligible are metal, rock, prog, prog rock, prog metal, and one list with a surprising amount of Korean and Japanese metal.

There will be multiple jazz-fusion players on mine.

INVALID!

[wolfking]

Actually, I have one who is more of a technical fusion jazz guy, but still plays a lot of prog and metal haha.  I also have one guy from a 90's modern rock band.

[ReaperKK]

This forum will have officially jumped the shark if Lars Ulrich makes the top 25. 

[TAC]

This forum will have officially jumped the shark if Lars Ulrich makes the top 25.

I'll be shocked if he doesn't make it.

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

This forum will have officially jumped the shark if Lars Ulrich makes the top 25.

He wasn't even on my short list.