Genesis Survivor 2022 - The Studio Albums - Round 9

[The Letter M]

The Studio Albums
Nursery Cryme
Foxtrot
Selling England By The Pound
A Trick Of The Tail
Wind And Wuthering
Duke

Round 8's Results:
Nursery Cryme 2 (16.7%)
Foxtrot 1 (8.3%)
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway 4 (33.3%)
A Trick Of The Tail 1 (8.3%)
Wind And Wuthering 2 (16.7%)
Duke 2 (16.7%)
Total Members Voted: 12

07. The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway
08. Genesis
09. Abacab
10. Invisible Touch
11. ...And Then There Were Three...
12. We Can't Dance
13. Trespass
14. ...Calling All Stations...
15. From Genesis To Revelation

-Marc.

[HOF]

This is tough. The 3 best Gabriel and the 3 best Collins albums left. I think Selling England has probably aged the least best for me, so I think I’m voting for it even though I would have probably called this my favorite PG Genesis album for a long time. I don’t know, it’s a tough call.

Update: I did in fact vote for Selling England By The Pound.

[jammindude]

Selling England is my #1 of all of them.

Voting Nursery Cryme again. Great moments, but the most flaws.

[CharlesPL]

trick

[Eldomm]

trick

[Mladen]

Trick, to save Nursery. I am surprised that Duke is the only album that doesn't have a single vote so far.

[HOF]

Selling England is my #1 of all of them.

Voting Nursery Cryme again. Great moments, but the most flaws.

It’s tough, and I could change my mind on this still, but Selling England for all its brilliance has More Fool Me and Epping Forest, plus After the Ordeal which is fine but not my favorite thing. Nursery Cryme doesn’t have a bad track on it (I’m not that fond of Harold the Barrel, but it’s fun). Foxtrot has the sleepy but inoffensive Time Table, and the ok Horizons, but everything else I really like. And Foxtrot was my first Gabriel-Genesis experience, so it holds a bit of an edge. All 3 have similar strengths, but I think Selling England had just a bit more fat than the others.

[romdrums]

Nursery to save both of the quartet albums.