Thanks again to everyone who submitted a list, participated in the thread, etc.! This one was fun.
And with that, here are the top two, which won't surprise anyone...
02 Kashmir
Appeared on 21 of 21 lists
Highest Finish: 1 (The Realm, jammindude)
15 Top 10 Finishes
30 years ago, this would have been top 5 for me, but the repetitive nature of the song made the song wear off me over time. I still think it is really good, and I ranked it 20th, but I can't say it is one of my top favorites anymore. That said, I totally get why it is for many, and I fully expected a top 3 finish for it.
01 Stairway to Heaven
Appeared on 21 of 21 lists
Highest Finish: 1 (Animal, Mladen, Stadler, TAC, hefaddy42)
18 Top 10 Finishes
Well done, DTF. Going in, I was hoping this wouldn't receive the "it's overrated" or "it's not as good anymore" treatment from submitters, and with 18 top 10 finishes and 5 number 1s, that was not the case. I ranked it 2nd because Over the Hills and Far Away has been my personal favorite for as long as I can remember, but this really is their best song. It is a monster classic for a reason. It is the perfect rock song, in just about every way imaginable.