And we enter into the top 10!
#10: Avengers: Age of Ultron
Highest ranking: #4 (DreamTeam, ZirconBlue)
Lowest ranking: #19 (faizoff)
Stats of note: This one probably has the widest disparity. It was all over the place, as you can see. In addition to the two #4 votes, it finished #6 on 3 other lists.
Given a lot of negative feedback after this one was released, I was not sure it would finish so high. This was only the second full Avengers ensemble film, and reviews were mixed. Lots loved it. Lots hated it. I think the haters mainly disliked the treatment of Ultron, from what I recall.
There was a lot going on in this film. In addition to the traditional Avengers, War Machine joined the fray for awhile. We also got Wanda and Pietro. And Klau. And Vision. And hints at Wakanda. For everything going it, it felt busy. But I think it worked.
I liked this film. I had it at #6, but am not bothered at all by a #10 finish. I probably had to suspend belief more for this film than most in the first 3 phases, but it was done just well enough that it didn't overly take me out of the moment. If anything to critique, I think maybe it's just that, for the threat Ultron posed, the resolution seemed fairly quick. But again, it was fine. There was lots in that third act that made up for it and made it work well enough. And for all its shortcomings, it is FAR better than the third act of just about any non-MCU or MCU phase 4 film.