I disagree, Viva was my first real insight into Katatonia and the one that good me hooked.TGCD has never really clicked with me, it lacks the brilliance of VE for me
Viva has some great stuff but I don't care much about songs like One Year from Now and Walking by a Wire. GCD is very consistent, The Itch is the only less than stellar song on the album and it should've been replaced with Dissolving Bonds.
This just prompted me to rank the Katatonia albums:
1. Great Cold Distance
2. Night is the New Day
3. Dead End Kings (may go even more up after more listens)
4. Brave Murder Day
5. Discouraged Ones
6. Last Fair Deal Gone Down
7. Viva Emptiness
8. Tonight's Decision
9. Dance of December Souls
The first 5 positions change all the time depending on mood - sometimes Discouraged Ones feels like the best album, sometimes Brave Murder Day is my favorite and so on. LFDGD also moves up occasionally but the bottom 3 remains the same pretty much all the time.