Puppies (Re)Discovery EP Roulette V.4 (The Final Art!)

[Crow]

well it's gotta be either "This starts off way better than it ends" or "I think I'm going to have a hard time getting past one song here"
and i guess uhhh the latter? idk

[jingle.boy]

Puppies. You have the best sig thingy eva!!

Channeling my inner King.

[Puppies_On_Acid]

well it's gotta be either "This starts off way better than it ends" or "I think I'm going to have a hard time getting past one song here"
and i guess uhhh the latter? idk

Indeed it is the latter.

[ariich]

Hoping for:

- Dang

But could also be:

- This starts off way better than it ends
- This is quite ambitious, not sure if it all works just yet

[Elite]

elite's EP definitely looks

weird 

That's probably what he was going for 

Indeed Is it any surprise though?

I did say this was probably the least good EP I made, but I still think it’s fun. Did I send an unexpected song?

And thanks for the artwork!! Looks awesome

[Crow]

well it's gotta be either "This starts off way better than it ends" or "I think I'm going to have a hard time getting past one song here"
and i guess uhhh the latter? idk

Indeed it is the latter.

the question is, which one
liturgy, i presume, which is my favorite on the EP, but 

[ariich]

well it's gotta be either "This starts off way better than it ends" or "I think I'm going to have a hard time getting past one song here"
and i guess uhhh the latter? idk

Indeed it is the latter.

the question is, which one
liturgy, i presume, which is my favorite on the EP, but 

Yeah I'm going to assume it's the Liturgy too. That song is... a bit much.

[Crow]

it's a bit much in the best way
i honestly think the aethereus song is heavier in a "lower tuned chugging blast of aggression" kinda way, so

[ariich]

it's a bit much in the best way
i honestly think the aethereus song is heavier in a "lower tuned chugging blast of aggression" kinda way, so

Yeah I'd agree, with Liturgy I don't think it's a matter of being super-overly-heavy, so much as being quite avant-garde and inaccessible (particularly vocally).

[Elite]

I checked out that track (God of Love) to see what the discussion is about. What a sick track, awesome stuff. I never knew I needed avant-garde black metal, but come to think of it based on stuff I like, it does kind of make sense that I would enjoy this

[Crow]

i cannot imagine any kind of black metal vocals are a problem for puppies 

[ariich]

i cannot imagine any kind of black metal vocals are a problem for puppies 

They don't really sound much like black metal vocals to me, but regardless you may well be right that Pup has no problem with them.

[King whatever and the whoosie whatsie]

Puppies. You have the best sig thingy eva!!

Channeling my inner King.

It doesn't help. Lol

[jingle.boy]

I think I've proven I suck ass at lining up my submissions and 1st impressions, and any of the remaining 6 could apply to mine, so I'll just

 

I'm wondering if Time Drops is the unexpected one though - given the singer.  Doubt it, but ya never know.

[TAC]

I think I've proven I suck ass

[wolfking]

 

[Puppies_On_Acid]

i cannot imagine any kind of black metal vocals are a problem for puppies 

I've been known to like some obscure harsh vocal styles... 

- Dang
- This starts off way better than it ends
Ariich - This is quite ambitious, not sure if it all works just yet
Wolfking - You went from to over the course of 3 rounds
Vmadera - This feels really unbalanced stylistically and song quality wise
TAC - There are some cool things going on, but some terrible vocals
Cyril - I think I'm going to have a hard time getting past one song here
- This probably contains the most unexpected song I've received so far this roulette
- Outside of a couple songs, this was actually more enjoyable than I was anticipating

well it's gotta be either "This starts off way better than it ends" or "I think I'm going to have a hard time getting past one song here"
and i guess uhhh the latter? idk

Indeed it is the latter.

the question is, which one
liturgy, i presume, which is my favorite on the EP, but 

I'm trying to remember if I introduced you to Liturgy back in the day. But either way, I kind of stopped following them after the disappointment that was The Ark Work. I gave H.A.Q.Q. a listen when it came out, but it didn't grab me enough to give it further listens.

Their most notable claim to fame (at least for me), is the fact they made the best and worst song of the year back in 2011. Glass Earth being the worst and Harmonia being the best.

I think I've proven I suck ass

I feel like this should be sig worthy, if not completely taken out of context 

[King whatever and the whoosie whatsie]

Please tell me I'm Dang. Lol

[wolfking]

I feel like this should be sig worthy, if not completely taken out of context 

Thanks for reminding me!

[jingle.boy]

I think I've proven I suck ass

I feel like this should be sig worthy, if not completely taken out of context 

Isn’t that how all sigs are supposed to be?

[Crow]

nah i found liturgy on my own  didn't know you were already into them tbh

[Deadeye21]

- This starts off way better than it ends
- This is quite ambitious, not sure if it all works just yet
- I think I'm going to have a hard time getting past one song here
- This probably contains the most unexpected song I've received so far this roulette

My entire EP is crap and I don’t know your tastes too well, so it could start better than it ends. I suppose it could be ambitious. Since (I think it was) Cyril laughed at Sail Away To Avalon, it could be a song that you can’t get past, and I know you weren’t a fan of Journey on the Waves of Time on As The Heavens Split Above. It could also be that using Pawns and Kings so soon after it’s release qualifies as unexpected?

[ariich]

[Deadeye21]

Am I far wrong?

I’ll start with ambitious, but not sure it works?

[Puppies_On_Acid]

- This starts off way better than it ends
- This is quite ambitious, not sure if it all works just yet
- I think I'm going to have a hard time getting past one song here
- This probably contains the most unexpected song I've received so far this roulette

My entire EP is crap and I don’t know your tastes too well, so it could start better than it ends. I suppose it could be ambitious. Since (I think it was) Cyril laughed at Sail Away To Avalon, it could be a song that you can’t get past, and I know you weren’t a fan of Journey on the Waves of Time on As The Heavens Split Above. It could also be that using Pawns and Kings so soon after it’s release qualifies as unexpected?

It can't be either of the middle two, because those have already been assigned 

[TAC]

Not sure who is taking longer assigning First Impressions....Deadeye or Puppies.

[Puppies_On_Acid]

Probably me.

[Deadeye21]

- This starts off way better than it ends
- This is quite ambitious, not sure if it all works just yet
- I think I'm going to have a hard time getting past one song here
- This probably contains the most unexpected song I've received so far this roulette

My entire EP is crap and I don’t know your tastes too well, so it could start better than it ends. I suppose it could be ambitious. Since (I think it was) Cyril laughed at Sail Away To Avalon, it could be a song that you can’t get past, and I know you weren’t a fan of Journey on the Waves of Time on As The Heavens Split Above. It could also be that using Pawns and Kings so soon after it’s release qualifies as unexpected?

It can't be either of the middle two, because those have already been assigned 

They didn’t have names next to them.

I guess it starts better than it ends?

[Puppies_On_Acid]

- This starts off way better than it ends
- This is quite ambitious, not sure if it all works just yet
- I think I'm going to have a hard time getting past one song here
- This probably contains the most unexpected song I've received so far this roulette

My entire EP is crap and I don’t know your tastes too well, so it could start better than it ends. I suppose it could be ambitious. Since (I think it was) Cyril laughed at Sail Away To Avalon, it could be a song that you can’t get past, and I know you weren’t a fan of Journey on the Waves of Time on As The Heavens Split Above. It could also be that using Pawns and Kings so soon after it’s release qualifies as unexpected?

It can't be either of the middle two, because those have already been assigned 

They didn’t have names next to them.

I guess it starts better than it ends?

I guess I should have also mentioned it was none of those.

Also post #1416 has the updated list with names.

[Puppies_On_Acid]

Please tell me I'm Dang. Lol

You are not.

[Deadeye21]

Am I “outside a couple of songs, this was better than expected”? Coz otherwise I’m “Dang” and I don’t know what that means.

[King whatever and the whoosie whatsie]

Crap.

[King whatever and the whoosie whatsie]

Then it's this.

This starts off way better than it ends

[TAC]

This starts off way better than it ends

[King whatever and the whoosie whatsie]

This starts off way better than it ends

That's what she said.