The TAC Roulette V.5...DTF Faves..WTF Am I Missing?? MastoDONE!

[ariich]

Sent.

One song could be a really obvious one, the other might be but to be honest I don't really know what approach others will take. Feels like the riskiest of all the rounds so far, so I'm very interested to see what people have sent.

[Kwyjibo]

Sent

and because Tim is starting to hate SW (or at least the vocals) someone should send Hatesong and Don't Hate Me, then at least the titles would be kinda fitting. 

[Elite]

What if I sent a PT song and a SW song, with another PT song as my wildcard and you end up hating the SW song most? Do I meed to send two wildcards?

[Buddyhunter1]

I kinda wanted to send Hatesong as it's one of my favorites, but I think TAC would, well, hate it.

Come to think of it, I didn't send any of the songs in my top three:
Trains
Hatesong
Russia On Ice

[425]

Cool to get some pretty solid scores on my Watershed picks! I kind of agree that the end of The Lotus Eater is not as strong as the beginning. Overall I think a downside of a lot of the longer metal Opeth songs is that they can be uneven, having really good sections mixed in with sections that are merely okay. Heir Apparent is one of the chief exceptions to that IMO, where the whole thing is good, so I'm happy with the 8.4

The Funeral Portrait as the top song on Blackwater Park (granted you did not get Patterns in the Ivy) is such an uncommon opinion, but it's one I low-key kind of agree with. At least, for me, it would be between Funeral Portrait and the title track.

Just sent Porcupine Tree's best song even though it's not intuitively one to send here.

[Evermind]

Hell yeah! My goal is to finish last now while still sending my favourite PT songs. Here we go!

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

I kinda wanted to send Hatesong as it's one of my favorites, but I think TAC would, well, hate it.

Come to think of it, I didn't send any of the songs in my top three:
Trains
Hatesong
Russia On Ice

I considered sending Russia on Ice, but I feel like Tim would find most of it boring.

[King Postwhore]

I sent my Sucks & Blows.

[Lonk]

I kinda wanted to send Hatesong as it's one of my favorites, but I think TAC would, well, hate it.

Come to think of it, I didn't send any of the songs in my top three:
Trains
Hatesong
Russia On Ice

I considered sending Russia on Ice, but I feel like Tim would find most of it boring.

Same.

[Stadler]

Lowest scores of the round.  At least I know it's not "me", since I'm basically picking stuff at random, but still....

[Evermind]

I kinda wanted to send Hatesong as it's one of my favorites, but I think TAC would, well, hate it.

Come to think of it, I didn't send any of the songs in my top three:
Trains
Hatesong
Russia On Ice

I considered sending Russia on Ice, but I feel like Tim would find most of it boring.

I wanted to send Trains but figured other people will. I did send a 10+ minutes song though.

[Crow]

I, too, sent a 10+ minute song to spite TAC specifically.
Trains would do very badly in this roulette, I feel. Watch me be wrong!

[King Postwhore]

Well I sent 2 over 10 minutes. 

[Buddyhunter1]

Since Deadwing is banned there's literally only like 3 10+ minute PT songs that wouldn't be absolute suicide to send

That number does jump up a bit if you're including solo SW stuff though...

[Kwyjibo]

I sent Linton Samuel Dawson and Jupiter Island just to annoy Tim





Not

[Buddyhunter1]

Someone send the full 40 minute Moonloop

[Kwyjibo]

Or the Metanoia improvisations or the complete Voyage 34 trip, the possibilities are endless.

[TAC]

OK, I'm home from work. Gotta peel through the PMs.

Just waiting for 3 2 more.

Elite
Stadler
LudwigVan

[Stadler]

Take me off the list!  I tortured myself sufficiently to get two songs to submit!

[Crow]

I am incredibly curious about what's being sent in this round, not gonna lie 

[Revenge319]

If I was participating, I would have sent two songs from The Incident, because I'm unsure if anyone else would have.

[romdrums]

Someone send the full 40 minute Moonloop

Can't because it's instrumental.  But, sending the 34 minute version of The Sky Moves Sideways and Raider II would be super trolly. .

[Buddyhunter1]

If I was participating, I would have sent two songs from The Incident, because I'm unsure if anyone else would have.

I included one in my possible three.

[TAC]

If I was participating, I would have sent two songs from The Incident, because I'm unsure if anyone else would have.

I included one in my possible three.

The good news..I eliminated one of your Wild Cards™ last night.
The bad news...I had to listen to it to do so.

 

[Crow]

I hope the eliminated wild card was a song I sent too

[ProfessorPeart]

I sent just over 30 min of music. He did tell me that someone already sent one of them, so I guess I sent less.

[Buddyhunter1]

If I was participating, I would have sent two songs from The Incident, because I'm unsure if anyone else would have.

I included one in my possible three.

The good news..I eliminated one of your Wild Cards™ last night.
The bad news...I had to listen to it to do so.

 

Keeping me in suspense as well, are ya?

I'm going to guess it's The Long One™ but my assumptions are often very wrong in this roulette

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

I sent Linton Samuel Dawson and Jupiter Island just to annoy Tim





Not

Oh jeez, that would have been hilarious! 

[TAC]

You know what's really jumping out at me, with what I've listened to so far. is the influence of Led Zeppelin.

Also..there is some great lead guitar playing.

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

You know what's really jumping out at me, with what I've listened to so far. is the influence of Led Zeppelin.

Also..there is some great lead guitar playing.

I do think that Steven Wilson is underrated as a guitarist.

[HOF]

You know what's really jumping out at me, with what I've listened to so far. is the influence of Led Zeppelin.

Also..there is some great lead guitar playing.

I do think that Steven Wilson is underrated as a guitarist.

I've always enjoyed his playing as well. He's a better guitarist than singer!

[LudwigVan]

OK, I'm home from work. Gotta peel through the PMs.

Just waiting for 3 2 more.

Elite
Stadler
LudwigVan

Sent!

[ariich]

You know what's really jumping out at me, with what I've listened to so far. is the influence of Led Zeppelin.

Also..there is some great lead guitar playing.

I do think that Steven Wilson is underrated as a guitarist.

I've always enjoyed his playing as well. He's a better guitarist than singer!

He's ok, but I've never found him anything special.

But any songs Tim's received from the two albums he did with Guthrie Govan, different story.

[Kwyjibo]

You know what's really jumping out at me, with what I've listened to so far. is the influence of Led Zeppelin.

Also..there is some great lead guitar playing.

He has his moments but I never really thought he was that good.

And I don't know what songs you received but his Pink Floyd influence is a lot bigger, but maybe more so in his earlier works.

[Elite]

What if I sent a PT song and a SW song, with another PT song as my wildcard and you end up hating the SW song most? Do I meed to send two wildcards?

I need to know!
This is the round I'm sending a wildcard in, haven't done it yet