The TAC Roulette V.5...DTF Faves..WTF Am I Missing?? MastoDONE!

[TAC]

Oh right..you guys have the same two songs.

[wolfking]

Outstanding!

[jingle.boy]

Not sure how Stadler.boy ended up sending the gem that is Condemned to the Gallows, I was real close myself but only wanted to send one track from Automata and that had to be Voice of Trespass.

So Chadler, who did you get to pick two BTBAM tracks for you?

This is how..

The 30th most listened to BTBAM song on last.fm is Astral Body (because Bill has 30k+ posts) -

The other song that screams "Stadler" to me is Condemned to the Gallows, as sometimes I would want to hang myself after reading a Stadler post

I went through BTBAM hell to pick those two songs! Meanwhile Chad rolls a d12 for Stads. 

I love both Tim and Bill, but I wasn't about to go thru BTBAM hell for either of them.

[v_clortho]

Someone should have sent their cover of The Dear Hunter's "The Tank".

[TAC]

First Impressions....solved.


I love the large amount of clean vocals in this song. [The Proverbial Bellow]

This song is fucked up, which I know could also be said for any other track in the playlist.[King Redeem/Queen Serene]

One of the leaders in the clubhouse.[Bad Habits]

Starts out pleasant and goes downhill from there.[Monochrome]

A short song with clean vocals.  Doesn't go anywhere though.[Millions]

Interesting song that I can't even link to the early BTBAM that I have heard.[The Coma Machine]

Really nice song with bits that don't hit you over the head.[Condemned To The Gallows]

The cleans in this were excellent. Fantastic ending.[Specular Reflection]

I couldn't wait for this to end. That is, until I got to the ending.
[Lunar Wilderness]

Well, that was extremely musical.[Silent Flight Parliament]

Has some older elements to it.[Astral Body]

Musically this is amazing.[Revolution In Limbo]

I hear a lot of Dream Theater in this.[Extremophile Elite]

This goes from Megadeth to Moby Dick to Helloween..and that's just the first three minutes.[Fix The Error]

That was a lot to chew on.[Blot]

I have no idea what I just heard.[Lay Your Ghosts To Rest]

This reminds me of Riot's Privilege Of Power and then goes all Hot For Teacher[Voice Of Trespass]

I liked this. I couldn't tell you what I just heard, but I liked it.[Turn On The Darkness]

The harsh vocal sections in this song are awful.[Never Seen/Future Shock]

The part right before the actual ending is Schenkeriffic![Memory Palace]

[ProfessorPeart]

Alright! It's a race against me for last place in this round!

This is like golf, right? Lowest score wins?

[TAC]

Yeah, Prof...you're gonna have a tough round.. and I hate golf.

Neal Morse is going to be sweet relief after this round.

I set it up that way purposely.

[ProfessorPeart]

Now I need to find 60+ minutes of Neal to send. Shouldn't be too hard. 

[King Postwhore]

You missing one of my songs?

[Lonk]

Well that's kind of promising...I think lol

Tim, if you get a chance, watch the video for Fix the Error. I honestly think it adds to the song, plus there's a MP cameo in the video.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=2q93v_nHmSM

[TAC]

You missing one of my songs?

Fixed. I was trying to forget it, honestly.

[King Postwhore]

 

[TAC]

Tim, if you get a chance, watch the video for Fix the Error. I honestly think it adds to the song, plus there's a MP cameo in the video.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=2q93v_nHmSM

Hah! That video is awesome! 
Are the guest drummers on the record, or are they just playing the parts in the video?

[Puppies_On_Acid]

Tim, if you get a chance, watch the video for Fix the Error. I honestly think it adds to the song, plus there's a MP cameo in the video.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=2q93v_nHmSM

Hah! That video is awesome! 
Are the guest drummers on the record, or are they just playing the parts in the video?

The guest drummers actually played those parts on the record.

[TAC]

That's cool. Who are the other guys? Are they in this roulette too?

That part is awesome!

[Lonk]

So it is MP, Navene Koperweis, Ken Schalk and Blake Richardson.

I only know Navene from Animals as Leaders. Never heard of ken. Blake is the drummer for BTTBAM.

[lonestar]

Me listening to Neal Morse trying to find songs to send...

[ariich]

Well, that was extremely musical.[Silent Flight Parliament]

I have no idea what I just heard.[Lay Your Ghosts To Rest]

One of these is more encouraging than the other!

[Elite]

Truth be told, I had no idea what I heard when I first listened to Lay Your Ghosts to Rest

[ariich]

Truth be told, I had no idea what I heard when I first listened to Lay Your Ghosts to Rest

I dunno, I don't think it's any crazier than basically all their other songs.

[TAC]

Truth be told, I had no idea what I heard when I first listened to Lay Your Ghosts to Rest

I dunno, I don't think it's any crazier than basically all their other songs.

It's tough to cold- listen to 20 BTBAM songs in a row. My ears were glazing over at points. The harsh vocals are so bad it was at times tough to differentiate the music underneath. Subsequent listens have helped clear it up though. It was the same way with a bunch of the Haken tunes.

Well, that was extremely musical.[Silent Flight Parliament]

I have no idea what I just heard.[Lay Your Ghosts To Rest]

One of these is more encouraging than the other!

Well, they're not getting the same score, so...yes. 

[Elite]

Truth be told, I had no idea what I heard when I first listened to Lay Your Ghosts to Rest

I dunno, I don't think it's any crazier than basically all their other songs.

Well, Parallax came out in a time that I wasn't really that interested in yet another BTBAM album, because they're so dense and I was looking for other stuff in music back then I guess. I remember that specifically during Lay Your Ghosts to Rest that I just zoned out and turned it off. I couldn't handle it at that point, despite loving Colors for example. That first experience with Parallax led me to not listening to it in full until years later. Coma Ecliptic did the same, but I did finish that one. The Automata albums pulled me back in to BTBAM and it was that year that I actually finished Parallax II for the first time

[Crow]

parallax II was the first BTBAM album where i felt like they kinda lost the plot a little and put emphasis on being overly complicated and progressive over actually writing compelling songs
this has kinda been the story of their albums since then really but i've liked automata and colors II more than parallax II and coma at the very least

[Buddyhunter1]

Parallax II is definitely my favorite of the post-TGM albums, but it certainly doesn't reach the heights of the two albums that came before it.

The Automatas are their lowest point since then, imo. Automata I was fine but very un-impactful and Automata II barely even feels like an album. Voice Of Trespass is just Bad Devil but worse (let's see if Tim disagrees ) and The Grid sucks as a closer.

[romdrums]

parallax II was the first BTBAM album where i felt like they kinda lost the plot a little and put emphasis on being overly complicated and progressive over actually writing compelling songs
this has kinda been the story of their albums since then really but i've liked automata and colors II more than parallax II and coma at the very least

See, I'm the exact opposite.  Parallax is where I think they finally figured out how to make all the wankery compelling, and able to serve a purpose rather than being there for its own sake.  Coma Ecliptic is an even further refinement of that idea.  With Automata and now Colors II, I think they're just tweaking the formula. 

[ariich]

parallax II was the first BTBAM album where i felt like they kinda lost the plot a little and put emphasis on being overly complicated and progressive over actually writing compelling songs
this has kinda been the story of their albums since then really but i've liked automata and colors II more than parallax II and coma at the very least

See, I'm the exact opposite.  Parallax is where I think they finally figured out how to make all the wankery compelling, and able to serve a purpose rather than being there for its own sake. 

Yes, this exactly. Parallax II is ridiculously great.

[Crow]

Maybe I'm alone in that but I was underwhelmed by it 

Even moreso underwhelmed by Coma though, which I have just never found very interesting or memorable

[TAC]

Interesting to read through the discussion.


I'm like 3 listens through the songs. Gonna start roughing out some writeups this afternoon. If I am efficient, I'm shooting for results before the Thanksgiving.

[Elite]

is that this weekend?

[Crow]

it is in three days

[HOF]

is that this weekend?

This coming Thursday.

[Elite]

it is in three days

brace yourselves

[ProfessorPeart]

I know something I will not be thankful for.

The BTBAM results.

[Buddyhunter1]

I know something I will not be thankful for.

The BTBAM results.

But they'll home hand-in-hand with the Neal Morse round!

...which I'll be even less thankful for!

[wolfking]

I've enjoyed everything pst Colors for the most part, although I couldn't get into Automata at all, that just is missing something for me.

Coma Ecliptic was a huge grower and I love it now.  Parallax is amazing and probably my second favourite after Colors.