I'll go on record as the sole TAU voter (so far).
I love Kaleidoscope very much, and have preferred it to the debut album since its release. The debut, to me, starts with two of the very best TA songs, and then has a rather unremarkable back half. On the other hand, TAU is consistent, but doesn't have anything I like as well as All of the Above. On the strength of that song, I give SMPTe the slight edge right now.