I think it being the first song on the album (as it often seems to be with DT) it can risk being an issue as, every time you put the album on in the early days, you’ve already heard the opening track a bunch of times. You then get impatient to get to the “new” stuff and can end up kind of resenting that song. I suppose it’s up to is to show restraint though and not listen to it a thousand times before the album comes out. I have got a bit better with that on recent releases from TA, LTE etc but I wasn’t a huge lover of the pre-released material so it was easier. DT is traditionally a problem for me in terms of overplaying singles!
Yeah, I hear you on that. I often find myself subconsciously feeling
exactly that way.
And it doesn't help if that first song doesn't immediately click with you either. To give an example, I wasn't immediately that fired up about TEI. I thought it was
okay, but wasn't really that special, and I didn't immediately like it all that much. Normally, that wouldn't really be much of a problem, except for: The tour started pretty soon after the album release, and I was still feeling that way about TEI. You wanna know who felt exactly the opposite and was completely in love with the song and pretty fired up about it? John Petrucci. And he asked me point blank after the show (or maybe it was even after the soundcheck--I don't remember for sure) what I thought about it. And I could see by his demeanor, his tone of voice, etc., that he was in love with the song and expected that I would be as well. I don't remember exactly what I said, but I was squirming quite a bit and said something pretty noncommittal because, while I didn't want to be disingenuous and fawn over something I didn't yet like all that much, but I also didn't want to pour cold water on his enthusiasm either. I think I basically said something along the lines of, "there's a lot of cool stuff going on with it, but I have to admit, I haven't really had a chance to digest it yet and give it its due." And then I quickly changed the subject to talk about one of the songs that I really
did love.
As a footnote to that story, I have since grown to like and appreciate it a lot more after having seen it performed live a couple of times and just letting it grow on me. But back to the main point of the discussion, that can impact initial impressions of a new album as a whole when having heard the opening track a bunch before album release.