Funny, I like it over their last 2 releases.
I'm not the type of fan who wants the band to sound like their best album over and over and over - but I really did not like No Line On The Horizon. I thought it was really lacking in songs.
The title track and magnificent are both great and maybe one more but I really didn't like the rest.
I'm all about SONGS and I thought Innocence and Experience were both GORGEOUS. Thank fuck they finally ditched Eno and Lanois. Their first 3 albums this millennium all sounded compressed to fuck.
The band have existed for 44 years... It's remarkable they're still making music this good.
But yeah American Soul isn't great.