Revenge319's relatively normal roulette: Love list complete! (FINAL RESULTS)

[jingle.boy]

Ok, if no one else is gonna call it, I will.  This has gone on long enough.

Iron Maiden
The Clairvoyant
Isle of Avalon
Journeyman

As usual, sending the worst songs by a band.   

You guys friggin' kill me.   I swear.   You MIGHT have had a point with "Plaster Caster", but c'mon, this is metal gold.   

And if you think THIS is bad, wait till NEXT round!! 

When you've got the choice of songs like 7th Son, Aces, Hallowed, Eagles, Children, Blood Brothers, Greater Good (to name just a few) .... and you send these three?



Next round predictions
Top Jimmy
Atomic Punk
Romeo Delight
Happy Trails

[Crow]

the frick's wrong with romeo delight?

[The Walrus]

Ok, if no one else is gonna call it, I will.  This has gone on long enough.

Iron Maiden
The Clairvoyant
Isle of Avalon
Journeyman

As usual, sending the worst songs by a band.   

You guys friggin' kill me.   I swear.   You MIGHT have had a point with "Plaster Caster", but c'mon, this is metal gold.   

And if you think THIS is bad, wait till NEXT round!! 

Yeah. Fool's gold. Jeeze, talk about scraping the barrel! 

[jingle.boy]

Nothing wrong with it... it just wouldn't crack the top 25 of too many people's Top VH songs.

@ Bill... it dawned on me that these submissions are like the Election.  325 million people, and these were the best two people your country could put up; 200ish IM songs, and these were the best three you could come up with??

[The Walrus]

@ Bill... it dawned on me that these submissions are like the Election.  325 million people, and these were the best two people your country could put up; 200ish IM songs, and these were the best three you could come up with??

 

[jingle.boy]

It's a good thing I took Pink Floyd away from him - he'd probably send Atom Heart Mother!!

[romdrums]

Stadler sending DT:

Status Seeker
Burning My Soul
Through Her Eyes
Constant Motion
Withered


 

[Buddyhunter1]

Hey, Wither and Constant Motion are great.

[twosuitsluke]

Stadler sending DT:

Status Seeker
Burning My Soul
Through Her Eyes
Constant Motion
Withered


 

I'm all for the Stadler ribbing, but hold on, Withered is a great song!

[jingle.boy]

Stadler sending DT:

Status Seeker
Burning My Soul
Through Her Eyes
Constant Motion
Withered


 

I'm all for the Stadler ribbing, but hold on, Withered is a great song!

Given the past tense, it WAS a great song.

[Crow]

the first three picks i get but the last two are pretty solid DT songs

if you wanted to send some absolute crap though why not Build Me Up, Break Me Down

[The Walrus]

BMUBMD is actually great

[King Postwhore]

BMUBMD is actually great

I'm not a fan of it either.  Least favorite on ADTOE.

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

It's a good thing I took Pink Floyd away from him - he'd probably send Atom Heart Mother!!

And Seamus

[twosuitsluke]

if you wanted to send some absolute crap though why not Build Me Up, Break Me Down

Or 95% of The Astonishing

[MoraWintersoul]

I disagree with literally everyone in the past two pages. I can't quote even half of the instances. I didn't even know this was possible. I have reached full DTF nirvana.

[Buddyhunter1]

if you wanted to send some absolute crap though why not Build Me Up, Break Me Down

Or 95% of The Astonishing

yes to both

I liked BMUBMD when the album first came out but man that song has aged like raw, unrefrigerated chicken. Or raw dog.

[Buddyhunter1]

I disagree with literally everyone in the past two pages. I can't quote even half of the instances. I didn't even know this was possible. I have reached full DTF nirvana.

You've reached peak internet!

[Stadler]

It's a good thing I took Pink Floyd away from him - he'd probably send Atom Heart Mother!!

DUDE.  No lie, I LOVE that fucking song.  Easily top 10 Floyd song for me.  I'm not even joking a little bit.

[Stadler]

I disagree with literally everyone in the past two pages. I can't quote even half of the instances. I didn't even know this was possible. I have reached full DTF nirvana.

Since many of the posts were disagreeing with ME, I'm going to take that as a big 

[jingle.boy]

It's a good thing I took Pink Floyd away from him - he'd probably send Atom Heart Mother!!

DUDE.  No lie, I LOVE that fucking song.  Easily top 10 Floyd song for me.  I'm not even joking a little bit.

Why am I not surprised?   

[Stadler]

It's a good thing I took Pink Floyd away from him - he'd probably send Atom Heart Mother!!

DUDE.  No lie, I LOVE that fucking song.  Easily top 10 Floyd song for me.  I'm not even joking a little bit.

Why am I not surprised?   

 

I can even say I've listened to that song within the last 72 hours.   

[HOF]

I don’t think I’ve heard any of the Maiden songs in question (or the Pink Floyd song for that matter), but that DT list is cracking me up.

[425]

Ok, if no one else is gonna call it, I will.  This has gone on long enough.

Iron Maiden
The Clairvoyant
Isle of Avalon
Journeyman

As usual, sending the best songs by a band.   

ftfy

Isle of Avalon is a particularly awesome choice. Top 5 Maiden song, and one of their more DT-esque moments.

[Stadler]

Thanks, 425; I'll get that $20 Venmo'd to you post haste! 

[The Walrus]

BMUBMD is actually great

I'm not a fan of it either.  Least favorite on ADTOE.

Hey. You. Shut up!

[TAC]

Next round predictions
Top Jimmy
Atomic Punk
Romeo Delight
Happy Trails

J- Boy, What is this? Romeo Delight is Grade A, and Atomic Punk is Grade A+.

Top Jimmy is fine.

[jingle.boy]

Next round predictions
Top Jimmy
Atomic Punk
Romeo Delight
Happy Trails

J- Boy, What is this? Romeo Delight is Grade A, and Atomic Punk is Grade A+.

Top Jimmy is fine.

I'm not saying they're bad, just that with an entire discography at ones disposal, those would not be my final 4 choices.

[King Postwhore]

BMUBMD is actually great

I'm not a fan of it either.  Least favorite on ADTOE.

Hey. You. Shut up!

Yes sir Stadler.

[TAC]

Next round predictions
Top Jimmy
Atomic Punk
Romeo Delight
Happy Trails

J- Boy, What is this? Romeo Delight is Grade A, and Atomic Punk is Grade A+.

Top Jimmy is fine.

I'm not saying they're bad, just that with an entire discography at ones disposal, those would not be my final 4 choices.

Atomic Punk would be in mine easily.

[jingle.boy]

Next round predictions
Top Jimmy
Atomic Punk
Romeo Delight
Happy Trails

J- Boy, What is this? Romeo Delight is Grade A, and Atomic Punk is Grade A+.

Top Jimmy is fine.

I'm not saying they're bad, just that with an entire discography at ones disposal, those would not be my final 4 choices.

Atomic Punk would be in mine easily.

[Revenge319]

Stadler sending DT:

Status Seeker
Burning My Soul
Through Her Eyes
Constant Motion
Withered


 

I'd say all of these songs are at least a 8/10.

[HOF]

Stadler sending DT:

Status Seeker
Burning My Soul
Through Her Eyes
Constant Motion
Withered


 

I'd say all of these songs are at least a 8/10.

I’ll give you Status Seaker, which I think is pretty cool (sounds like Rush).

[Buddyhunter1]

Stadler sending DT:

Status Seeker
Burning My Soul
Through Her Eyes
Constant Motion
Withered


 

I'd say all of these songs are at least a 8/10.

No
Definitely not
DEFINITELY NOT
Yeah
Probably

[425]

I'm not saying they're bad, just that with an entire discography at ones disposal, those would not be my final 4 choices.

Maybe I'm strange, but this isn't always the approach I take. I often try to pick the song from the top ~10% of a band's discography that I think the host will be most likely to enjoy. And in this case where multiple songs are sent, another consideration is trying to give a broad representative of a band's sound.