BOOH is one of those works that transcends. I happen to like Meat; he used to live the next town over from me, and while I never met him personally, I did see him once coaching his daughter's softball; they played at a field at a high school I played against. I wouldn't say I love all his music, I wouldn't say I love that "genre" of music, but I can put on BOOH I and almost literally sing through the entire album. It's just a part of the tapestry, and for good reason. The Phil Rizzuto thing is a SHADE dated; I grew up listening to Phil call the Yankee games on WPIX 11, so that was a hometown favorite, but I can imagine people hearing that now and thinking "who the hell is that weird guy talking over the track???". But the rest? That's a quality record, top to bottom, independent of the artist, the time, or the genre. (I liked II and III, but neither touch the original lightning in a bottle).
Trivia: Ellen Foley sings the duet with Meat on record, not Karla DeVito (who toured with the band and appeared in the video). Foley now teaches at what started as the "School Of Rock"; kids from that school opened the Jon Anderson show I saw about a year ago in Ridgefield. They were excellent; 17 year old high school kids jamming out on Yes ("South Side Of The Sky") and Steely Dan tunes (among others). I smashed my guitar minutes after arriving home after the show.