From a personal standpoint, I'm baffled at the love that TGD gets. I'm doing a run through DT's albums, and I'm finishing SFAM later today, so I'll give TGD another listen soon.
I listened to TGD again over the weekend, and my opinion remains unchanged. The song is just a mess...especially the intro, which seems to run on and on and on... There is a little bit near the end that's pretty good, but it's very short and quickly gives way to a bit of JP/JR wankery. I did, however, revise my opinion about Disappear from bad to not bad but mostly boring.