Puppies' Rush Roulette V.3 (Ultimate Post-Roulette Mega Rundown!)

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

Katatonia sent Lethean

It's funny, but I actually considered unbanning Katatonia just for Lethean. Only problem is, I know all their albums extremely well. Been listening to them for close to 20 years now...

[Lethean]

Puppies,    I'm glad you considered it!

So... if Katatonia wasn't banned and I were to send you Buildings, what round would it be?

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

Puppies,    I'm glad you considered it!

So... if Katatonia wasn't banned and I were to send you Buildings, what round would it be?

I could potentially see that song fitting in with rounds 6, 8, or 9.

[Tomislav95]

hi

[TAC]

Sent for Round 1 and half of Round 2.

[Lethean]

Puppies,    I'm glad you considered it!

So... if Katatonia wasn't banned and I were to send you Buildings, what round would it be?

I could potentially see that song fitting in with rounds 6, 8, or 9.

No, no, and no.  But I'm curious how you think it would fit since it might give me (and everyone else) some ideas for how to do this.

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

hi

Are you signing up?

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

Puppies,    I'm glad you considered it!

So... if Katatonia wasn't banned and I were to send you Buildings, what round would it be?

I could potentially see that song fitting in with rounds 6, 8, or 9.

No, no, and no.  But I'm curious how you think it would fit since it might give me (and everyone else) some ideas for how to do this.

But, it's all about how YOU interpret the lyrics and music. Everyone sees things differently. I'm more interested in how other people draw similarities between Rush and other bands.

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

Since some of you seems to be having trouble, I've added my thoughts (at least for round 1 for now) in the OP in the Themes section.

[Crow]

for real though i'm /out 

[The Walrus]

I gotta really work for a good score in Pup's roulette - although I think I did really well in the last one? could be wrong - so although I know there's plenty of time to still sign up, don't worry if you don't get mine for a while. I'm really going to try to find some interesting new stuff this time around

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

for real though i'm /out 

Ok, byeeeeeeee 

I gotta really work for a good score in Pup's roulette - although I think I did really well in the last one? could be wrong - so although I know there's plenty of time to still sign up, don't worry if you don't get mine for a while. I'm really going to try to find some interesting new stuff this time around

Take your time, I'll set a deadline of Feb 2nd for round 1 submissions.

[Lethean]

Puppies,    I'm glad you considered it!

So... if Katatonia wasn't banned and I were to send you Buildings, what round would it be?

I could potentially see that song fitting in with rounds 6, 8, or 9.

No, no, and no.  But I'm curious how you think it would fit since it might give me (and everyone else) some ideas for how to do this.

But, it's all about how YOU interpret the lyrics and music. Everyone sees things differently. I'm more interested in how other people draw similarities between Rush and other bands.

*sighs*

[TAC]

Lethean...lost without Katatonia.

[Lethean]

Banned list

I’m going to cut down the banned list a little bit from last time. You will still need to check my RYM page to make sure I haven’t rated a particular album (or you can PM and ask if you are lazy (I might dock a point for this ) If an album is rated on RYM, it's banned.
RYM

Puppies, if an album is listed on your page but doesn't have a star rating at all, is it fair game?

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

Banned list

I’m going to cut down the banned list a little bit from last time. You will still need to check my RYM page to make sure I haven’t rated a particular album (or you can PM and ask if you are lazy (I might dock a point for this ) If an album is rated on RYM, it's banned.
RYM

Puppies, if an album is listed on your page but doesn't have a star rating at all, is it fair game?

Anything without a star rating is fair game. At least is should be, like I outlined in the rules, I do reserve the right to reject a submission if it is something I forgot to put on my banned list and/or forgot to rate on RYM. Having said that, I've been pretty thorough with my RYM ratings and banned list, so this shouldn't be an issue.

[Tomislav95]

hi

Are you signing up?

I'll give it a shot!

[The Walrus]

EDIT: I was gonna send mine right away just to get it out of the way... til I noticed the artist I was gonna send had 4 stars on RYM  welp

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

EDIT: I was gonna send mine right away just to get it out of the way... til I noticed the artist I was gonna send had 4 stars on RYM  welp

Just remember that only albums that are rated are banned. If it was a song on an album that isn't rated it's ok to send.

[ariich]

Just touching in to say that, as reigning champion, I am of course in! Even though (as only a moderate Rush fan) the theme will mean a reasonable amount of effort.

[Nekov]

This is gonna be hard given that the banned list is huge! But what the hell, I'm up for the challenge.
I have a technical question since I haven't found it in the rules: Can I send 2 songs from the same artist per round? Or do they need to be 2 different artists?
I'm mainly asking because if the second is the case I might struggle to have enough music to send 

[Stadler]

Any room on the boat?  I have a baby.  My God, man, I have a BABY!   

Seriously, if you have a spot, I'd play.

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

This is gonna be hard given that the banned list is huge! But what the hell, I'm up for the challenge.
I have a technical question since I haven't found it in the rules: Can I send 2 songs from the same artist per round? Or do they need to be 2 different artists?
I'm mainly asking because if the second is the case I might struggle to have enough music to send 

Ah yes, I forgot to specify. You can indeed send the same artist for both songs in a round. I'll amend the rules.

Any room on the boat?  I have a baby.  My God, man, I have a BABY!   

Seriously, if you have a spot, I'd play.

Your in!! Baby and all!

[The Walrus]

Hear that, Stads? URINE!

[Stadler]

I tried that once in college, but I was drunk at the time.  Wasn't for me. 

Clarification:  Banned list AND RYM rated albums, or JUST the RYM rated albums FOR the banned bands?

[Nekov]

Sent for round 1. Probably gonna get rejected for theme related reasons 

[TAC]

Hear that, Stads? URINE!

 

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

I tried that once in college, but I was drunk at the time.  Wasn't for me. 

Clarification:  Banned list AND RYM rated albums, or JUST the RYM rated albums FOR the banned bands?

The former. Banned list is all bands that are completely banned regardless if they are rated on RYM or not.

[Train of Naught]

Sent! Hope the connections between the songs and the Rush albums are not too vague
I probably need a couple rounds to figure you out again, I think I made it to the finals last time but I also feel like sometimes I don't know you at all

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

but I also feel like sometimes I don't know you at all

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

Stadler, you will need to resend one of your songs. Also your inbox is full...

[TAC]

Stadler must have the smallest fucking inbox. Geezus.

[King Puppies and the Acid Guppies]

Stadler must have the smallest fucking inbox. Geezus.

Ariich must have made his inbox tiny on purpose. Can't let Stadler have that much power. 

[TAC]

I hate my inbox being too full. I like to keep it to one page always.