New DT live album/DVD

[devieira73]

From Facebook:
London!  We've added a second date at the Eventim Apollo next year, tickets go on sale this Friday at 10am. http://gigst.rs/DreamTheater

We are also excited to announce that we will be  filming both of these shows, stay tuned for more news on that!
Indeed

Edit: sorry, it was already on DoT thread.

[MinistroRaven]

good news

[Chino]

So does this mean the Astonishing didn't get one because it was seen as a flop and not because of a lack of demand for live releases in general?

[Trav86]

So does this mean the Astonishing didn't get one because it was seen as a flop and not because of a lack of demand for live releases in general?

Yeah, probably.

[Volante99]

Yeah it is a shame they couldn’t get a proshoot to document an Astonishing concert and release it for the fans. I’m not a huge Astonishing fan myself, but even I must admit that was *quite* the live show.


I get that it sells DVDs but I’m hoping they resist the temptation to add an orchestra. Last thing I want to hear/see is the London Junior Varsity B-Squad Symphony Orchestra trying to keep up with The Dance of Eternity.

[YtseJamittaja]

I get that it sells DVDs but I’m hoping they resist the temptation to add an orchestra. Last thing I want to hear/see is the London Junior Varsity B-Squad Symphony Orchestra trying to keep up with The Dance of Eternity.

They have done it twice so naah, they should try something new like guest musicians on stage or something like that

[Rob24]

I mean, in general, dropping a live release for every album can seem a bit over the top, so leaving one out kinda makes sense to me.

[nikatapi]

Good that they're filming this.
The fact that they will be playing SFAM in its entirety will make the DVD live up to some high expectations.

[gmillerdrake]

Yeah it is a shame they couldn’t get a proshoot to document an Astonishing concert and release it for the fans......... that was *quite* the live show.

It was one of the best live shows I've seen. That album was written to be played and experienced live.....really bummed there won't be a DVD of it anytime soon.

[gzarruk]

Since this is going to be recorded next year, they could make another setlist change and/or rotate an A setlist and a B setlist for the first half of the show and the encore, with the 2nd half being SFAM. They record both nights and release an album with a varied setlist, hopefully with most of D/T, and a great live version of SFAM. Could be worse

[pg1067]

I get that it sells DVDs but I’m hoping they resist the temptation to add an orchestra. Last thing I want to hear/see is the London Junior Varsity B-Squad Symphony Orchestra trying to keep up with The Dance of Eternity.

Is that supposed to be a jab at the Berklee College of Music Orchestra that played on Bt4W?  The notion that a classically trained orchestra would have difficulty keeping up with any DT song is utterly laughable.

They have done it twice so naah, they should try something new like guest musicians on stage or something like that

Agree.

[bosk1]

I get that it sells DVDs but I’m hoping they resist the temptation to add an orchestra. Last thing I want to hear/see is the London Junior Varsity B-Squad Symphony Orchestra trying to keep up with The Dance of Eternity.

Is that supposed to be a jab at the Berklee College of Music Orchestra that played on Bt4W?  The notion that a classically trained orchestra would have difficulty keeping up with any DT song is utterly laughable.

Well, yes and no.  The orchestration itself for any DT song would likely be well within their grasp.  But on the other hand, even VERY well educated and experienced classical musicians (and conductors, for that matter) typically do not deal on any regular basis with very many odd time signatures or pieces with so many time signature changes.  I am not saying it would be beyond an orchestra's ability by any stretch.  But I am confident that, for many, it would take some work to get up to speed.

[EPIC Outro]

I want a live choir version of Dance of Eternity.

[pg1067]

I want a live choir version of Dance of Eternity.

Well...there's that unaired episode of Glee.   

[efx]

I get that it sells DVDs but I’m hoping they resist the temptation to add an orchestra. Last thing I want to hear/see is the London Junior Varsity B-Squad Symphony Orchestra trying to keep up with The Dance of Eternity.

Is that supposed to be a jab at the Berklee College of Music Orchestra that played on Bt4W?  The notion that a classically trained orchestra would have difficulty keeping up with any DT song is utterly laughable.

Well, yes and no.  The orchestration itself for any DT song would likely be well within their grasp.  But on the other hand, even VERY well educated and experienced classical musicians (and conductors, for that matter) typically do not deal on any regular basis with very many odd time signatures or pieces with so many time signature changes.  I am not saying it would be beyond an orchestra's ability by any stretch.  But I am confident that, for many, it would take some work to get up to speed.

As a classically trained musician I would have to say that's not remotely true. While the standard repertoire (i.e classical through romantic) is pretty straightforward rhythmically, anyone who has gone through conservatory training will have played and been exposed to enough 20th century music that would easily equal if not surpass the DT stuff in any sort of meter complexity.

[bosk1]

None of what you just typed contradicts what I said.

[pg1067]

I get that it sells DVDs but I’m hoping they resist the temptation to add an orchestra. Last thing I want to hear/see is the London Junior Varsity B-Squad Symphony Orchestra trying to keep up with The Dance of Eternity.

Is that supposed to be a jab at the Berklee College of Music Orchestra that played on Bt4W?  The notion that a classically trained orchestra would have difficulty keeping up with any DT song is utterly laughable.

Well, yes and no.  The orchestration itself for any DT song would likely be well within their grasp.  But on the other hand, even VERY well educated and experienced classical musicians (and conductors, for that matter) typically do not deal on any regular basis with very many odd time signatures or pieces with so many time signature changes.  I am not saying it would be beyond an orchestra's ability by any stretch.  But I am confident that, for many, it would take some work to get up to speed.

As a classically trained musician I would have to say that's not remotely true. While the standard repertoire (i.e classical through romantic) is pretty straightforward rhythmically, anyone who has gone through conservatory training will have played and been exposed to enough 20th century music that would easily equal if not surpass the DT stuff in any sort of meter complexity.

Ummm...you disagreed with Bosk and then basically wrote exactly what he wrote but just in different words (with a non sequitur thrown in)

[TAC]

I get that it sells DVDs but I’m hoping they resist the temptation to add an orchestra. Last thing I want to hear/see is the London Junior Varsity B-Squad Symphony Orchestra trying to keep up with The Dance of Eternity.

Is that supposed to be a jab at the Berklee College of Music Orchestra that played on Bt4W?  The notion that a classically trained orchestra would have difficulty keeping up with any DT song is utterly laughable.

But they didn't even end up using them on the live album anyway. Didn't they just dub in the studio version? Do I have this wrong?

[bosk1]

Yes, you have it wrong.

[TAC]

Yes, you have it wrong.

Are you saying that it IS the actual live performance from the concert on the live album?

I thought people with much better ears than mine had debunked that.

[JayOctavarium]

From what I understand, it's mixed with Jordan's keys, and the keys are a tad louder than the orchestra.

[faizoff]

This is great news, hopefully this time around they get a good mix done. The SFAM concert was excellent and the new tracks ruled live. Won't be able to make it to any show that are playing the other tracks that didn't play in my show.

[|KirK|]

I'm going to be there for the second night, flying there from Italy.
It'll be a special night for sure, but I hope they have something different in mind, some new ideas...
We already have a DVD with SFAM in its entirety, and it's probably my favorite one. They also made a short tribute with the orchestra to this album in "Breaking the fourth wall".
I'm afraid people will just complain about James and his voice, or Mike vs Mike.
Btw, I can't wait!!!

[The Curious Orange]

I'm there the first night, I'm seriously debating going the second night too. It's a serious waste of money...

[faizoff]

Has there been any update on this? Any possible release date? I imagine it's the one thing that can be worked on during the pandemic.

[gzarruk]

Has there been any update on this? Any possible release date? I imagine it's the one thing that can be worked on during the pandemic.

IIRC, James said it was to be released around November. JP said he isn't sure about the release date, but that it's currently being worked on.