Bump! I watched all four Toy Stories this weekend. Not that it was in doubt, but it reaffirmed my opinion that Toy Story is one of the greatest film/entertainment franchises ever. All 4 films are quality. So, I polled my Facebook as to how people would rank them from favorite to least, and this is what I've got so far, including my own (1 4 3 2):
123 (haven't seen 4) x2
1234
1243
1432 x3
1423 x2
3124 x2
3241
3412
3421
Interesting that nobody put 4 as their favorite, or 2.
1 remains one of the greatest movies of all time, I think. It's almost completely flawless, and still makes me laugh more than the rest. I'm pretty sure it was also the first movie I ever saw in theaters. 2 is not bad, I still love it, but it lacks a certain charm that the other three have, and I really don't care for Jesse or the Prospector in this movie, and Al is a total knob. 3 brings tears to my eyes in the first and last scenes. I suppose it helps that I was 4 when the first movie came out and Pixar did an incredible job at making Andy feel so relatable to me between his age, love of toys and imagination, and realizing how he needs to let go and move on. 4 is a film that I'd call unnecessary and yet they still did a remarkable job with it. I love what they did with Bo Peep's character, Key & Peele's characters are hilarious, and it feels like Pixar never lost what made Toy Story magical to me.
Just like after 3 wrapped, I would be perfectly fine if 4 was the final entry in the series. After all, if 8 years from now they come out with Toy Story 5, Tom Hanks and Tim Allen will be in their 70s, and I think that for certain would be the final entry (I can't see them ever doing a Toy Story without Buzz or Woody, nevermind Hanks and Allen not voicing them - I know Patrick Warburton voiced Buzz in that animated series, but let's be honest, almost nobody cares about that). If they do it, I have no doubt Pixar would knock it out of the park - but I'm blanking on what other themes they could possibly go with after 2 that were explicitly about growing up, moving on, loss, and learning to forge your own path.