Still digesting the 4th record. It's better than my initial impression, I like He Once Was, Underneath The Orphan Moon and Somewhere North Of Nowhere best. Bulletprof is another good song, but it's not that different from the Spock's Beard version, I wonder why they felt the need to record it again.
But all in all this record ranks 3rd or 4th, not sure yet.
I've spun it several more times since release and quite enjoy it. It's hard to rank these albums after awhile because they've all come out in such short time from each other that after awhile, they start to blend together, for better or worse. At least the band has a fairly consistent sound and style that is recognizable and not a straight rip-off of Spock's Beard, though there are still some Beard-isms here and there, which seems unavoidable. I still like their second album the most, but this might tie for 2nd with the third album, with their debut sitting at the bottom, but by no means is it a BAD album, just my least favorite over-all.
Not sure what to think if they are already recording the next one. Seems to me that every song John Boegehold writes gets recorded. Maybe it would be better to write some more and then chose the best. I'm all for quality over quantity.
Well it's telling that their last two albums have had "bonus tracks" tacked on the end, so it really does seem like John is releasing almost every song he deems fit to record for P-SA. It should be reiterated that this band began as an outlet for John's proggier music, and that from the outset, it was going to be a yearly endeavor. With four albums in about four years, he shows no signs of slowing, and I'm not sure if that's a good thing or not. So far, the songs and albums have all been quite enjoyable, IMO, so I'm not going to turn away from more P-SA, but I hope the quality is about the same going forward. So far, they're all at least 7/10 rated for me, with the debut being around a 7/10 but the rest at least an 8 or 9, if I had to put rating on them. And in the absence of new Spock's Beard material, this is the best way to get new prog rock from Ted and Dave, who is one of the most underrated bassists in prog rock (still!).
-Marc.