General > Polls/Survivors
Spock's Beard Survivor 2019 - Results & Discussion
Elite:
--- Quote from: The Letter M on April 06, 2019, 11:25:15 AM ---Some points to discuss if anyone has any opinions one way or the other:
1- I was wondering if anyone would think it better or worse if I split up "A Flash Before My Eyes" into its six separate tracks for the Octane survivor. The last three times I've done the SB Survivor, it was done as one track, and I don't think anyone really objected to it, but I was wondering if changing it would make any difference for anyone here?
--- End quote ---
One track please, even though the band plays parts of it live, without doing the whole song.
--- Quote from: The Letter M on April 06, 2019, 11:25:15 AM ---2- Should I continue to include the covers in the Bonus Tracks/B-Side/Non-Album Songs survivor? I did last time, and there's only four of them. Like Snow (and other double-albums I've run in the past), this B-Sides Survivor will probably start with multiple-vote/multi-elimination rounds to help narrow it down pretty quickly, and help voters knock out multiple songs they probably don't like as much as the others, rather than drag the whole thing out for 25 rounds.
--- End quote ---
I don't know half the B-sides, so I will abstain for the most part of the Survivor, only to show up in the last round to make sure both Their Names Escape Me and Falling for Forever win.
--- Quote from: The Letter M on April 06, 2019, 11:25:15 AM ---3- Japanese Exclusive Bonus Tracks. There are three that I am aware of, two from SB9 ("A Hypernova Explosion" and "Red Sea") and one from Noise Floor ("Save Our Souls"). Should I bother including them, since I'm sure I'm one of the few SB fans that actually owns or have actually even heard them?
-Marc.
--- End quote ---
I have never heard them, but I haven't heard a lot of the bonus tracks.
Mladen:
I can't make up my mind regarding the suites. :lol
Whichever way you choose to approach them has its arguments, so you might as well trust your judgement.
The Letter M:
The Light's Final Round's Results:
The Light 6 (60%)
The Water 4 (40%)
1. The Water
2. The Light
3. Go The Way You Go
4. On The Edge
Well, in a slight twist to the last two times I've run this survivor, "The Light" places second instead of first, with the epic track "The Water" placing first! It's no big deal, though, since both songs will move into the finals with "Go The Way You Go" going to the Consolation Rounds.
-Marc.
DTA:
Glad to see The Water win out. The Light is certainly more iconic, but I think The Water is just the more impactful song overall.
RoeDent:
Are you going to add the songs to the Consolation and Finals lists above as they qualify?
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version