I used to be in a very similar spot as Adami. At some point I realized that it was my history with DT (i.e. them being my undisputed #1 band for almost two decades) made me judge their current output with a measuring stick they simply never will live up to. Simply ain't gonna happen from this point on.
Interestingly though, that realization made me split DT in two: the IAW->6DOIT band that I still hold dearly in my heart, and the ToT->Now band that I'm only so-so into. But because of that split, me only being so-so into modern DT is fine, and I listen to new releases with mild interest. A few songs I like, a lot of them I don't. But that's ok enough for me for modern DT.
Well that's not really where I'm at. I'm not comparing their new stuff with their old stuff. I still really love Illumination Theory (well most of it anyway) and a BAI.
I just don't connect with the new music or lyrics. I don't judge a band by how good they are compared to what they did. Just if I like it or not. I'm one of the guys who loves when a band changes and evolves. I just have to like the output. DT's current philosophy on music and lyrics doesn't do much for me.
This is fine, but if you state it’s not about judging and comparing and just if you like it or not, then why make a statement that you lose interest if JM is writing the lyrics? Surely based off that it wouldn’t be about who wrote it, just you like the finished product. Odd as well when he penned the lyrics for one of the modern songs you listed you do actually enjoy in BAI.
In any case, not trying to start up a shitstorm, I just think there are some inconsistencies in some of the comments. Which is understandable if you feel you aren’t connecting much with the music anymore. Hopefully there may be some nice moments on the new album that restore something for you
My statement about JM was meant to illustrate how disappointed I was that this was the case. I really liked his lyrics pre-SFAM. So while you could call that comparing, it's not that I need his lyrics to be as good as they were then and I can't like them for what they are, it's that I just don't like them, and it's a shame considering how good they used to be. And I do like BAI.....musically. I like the vocals too, just don't care much for the lyrics. It's not like I hear them and go "OH GOD THESE LYRICS RUIN EVERYTHING" I just kind of ignore them because they, to me, feel very bland and cliche.
Also why are you looking for inconsistencies? If someone says they prefer MM era of MP era, are they subject to this level of critical analysis? Or are only positive opinions welcome? Are you trying to prove I have some kind of ulterior motive or something? I mean, I just don't connect with much of it anymore and I find a lot of it to be mechanical, cliche, and boring. It sucks, but it's just what it is. My tastes have obviously just changed.
I'm not looking for inconsistencies at all. It's just what seems to appear these days when you write posts. Which like you stated, may come from the result that you have kinda moved past what the band is offering - and that is ok. And of course it's not only positive opinions that are welcome. But when a majority of posts seem to have a predictable, negative spin, then that also becomes a little tiresome. Because they have put out some great, recent music.
As a comparison, a few years ago, one of our friends came over and basically outstayed his welcome. My ex-wife was an angry soul, and it got to the point that even if he just greeted her with a "good morning", she would get pissed off, as she just wanted him gone. Poor bloke couldn't even cheerfully greet her by the end
A bit of a lighthearted example, but I do wonder with some who don't like DT'S newer stuff, is there a bit of this going on? As they went in a different direction possibly to some of the fans tates, can some just not bring themselves to like much of anything new they do, even if it's pretty good? Not saying this is the case with you, but something that always crossed my mind. In any case, no hard feelings mate, to each his own. Peace